Matthew Cuthbert, the quiet and kind-hearted brother of Marilla, serves as Anne Shirley’s steadfast father figure and a crucial cornerstone of Green Gables. His sudden and unexpected death in Episode 7 of Season 3, titled “A Stronger Will Than Mine,” marks one of the most emotionally devastating moments in Anne with an E.
Matthew’s Impact and the Significance of His Death
Matthew’s passing is more than just the loss of a character; it’s the loss of Anne’s protector, her confidante, and the person who truly understood and accepted her from the very beginning. He represented stability, unconditional love, and the unwavering belief in Anne’s potential.
His death dramatically shifts the dynamics at Green Gables, impacting Anne, Marilla, and the entire Avonlea community. It forces Anne to confront mortality and consider her future, ultimately leading her to make a selfless decision that showcases her maturity and devotion. The scene itself is handled with great sensitivity, emphasizing the shock and grief experienced by those closest to him. It’s a masterclass in dramatic storytelling, highlighting the fragility of life and the enduring power of family (both biological and chosen).
Detailing the Circumstances Surrounding Matthew’s Death
Matthew’s death is a direct result of learning about the potential loss of Green Gables. He collapses after hearing the news of the bank’s failure and the subsequent threat of losing their beloved home. The stress and worry are too much for his already weakened heart.
This ties directly into the theme of financial hardship prevalent in the series. The Cuthberts, while hardworking, weren’t wealthy. The potential loss of their livelihood is a significant blow, highlighting the vulnerability of farmers in that era. Matthew’s deep connection to the land and to Green Gables itself amplified the impact of the news, ultimately leading to his demise.
The Aftermath: Anne’s Decision and Green Gables’ Future
Following Matthew’s death, Anne makes the momentous decision to stay at Green Gables and become a teacher in Carmody, sacrificing her dream of attending Queens College in order to help Marilla and keep their home. This act of selflessness demonstrates her profound love and gratitude for the Cuthberts.
This decision is a turning point for Anne. It marks her transition from a hopeful, imaginative girl to a responsible and compassionate young woman. She embraces her duty to Marilla and to the memory of Matthew, solidifying her place as an integral part of the Green Gables legacy. The storyline beautifully showcases the themes of sacrifice, loyalty, and the evolving definition of family.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Matthew Cuthbert’s Death in Anne with an E
Why did Matthew die so suddenly?
Matthew’s death, while seemingly sudden, was foreshadowed by his advanced age and the inherent stress of farm life. The news about the bank failure acted as the tipping point, triggering a heart attack due to the overwhelming stress and worry about losing Green Gables. The unexpected nature of his passing reflects the unpredictable nature of life itself.
How does Anne react to Matthew’s death?
Anne is devastated by Matthew’s death. Her reaction is filled with profound grief and a sense of loss. She mourns not only the loss of a father figure but also the loss of the unwavering support and love he provided. However, Anne channels her grief into a sense of responsibility, determined to protect Marilla and Green Gables in Matthew’s memory. Her resilience in the face of immense sorrow is a testament to her character.
What episode number is Matthew’s funeral in?
Matthew’s funeral takes place in Episode 8 of Season 3, titled “Great and Sudden Change.” This episode focuses on the aftermath of his death, the grieving process, and Anne’s decision to stay at Green Gables.
What was Matthew’s relationship with Anne like?
Matthew and Anne shared a unique and incredibly special bond. Matthew was immediately captivated by Anne’s unique personality and her bright imagination. He provided her with the unconditional love and acceptance she desperately craved, becoming the father figure she never had. Their relationship was one of quiet understanding and mutual respect.
How does Marilla react to Matthew’s death?
Marilla is deeply affected by Matthew’s death. She loses her brother and her lifelong companion. While she tries to remain strong for Anne, the loss is evident in her quiet grief and her reliance on Anne for support. Matthew’s passing leaves a significant void in Marilla’s life, forcing her to confront her own mortality and loneliness.
Did Matthew know he was going to die?
There’s no indication that Matthew had any premonition of his death. His passing was sudden and unexpected, triggered by the stress of the financial crisis. He appeared healthy enough beforehand, although his age made him more vulnerable. This element of surprise underscores the fragility of life and the unpredictability of death.
How does Matthew’s death affect Gilbert Blythe?
While not directly impacting Gilbert in the same way as Anne or Marilla, Matthew’s death serves as a reminder of the preciousness of life and the importance of pursuing his dreams. It likely reinforces his admiration for Anne’s resilience and her dedication to her family. His passing contributes to Gilbert’s growing maturity and his deeper understanding of the world.
Why did the showrunners choose to kill off Matthew?
Killing off a beloved character like Matthew serves several narrative purposes. It injects a dose of realism into the story, highlighting the challenges and hardships of life in rural Prince Edward Island. It also forces Anne to grow and mature, taking on new responsibilities and making difficult choices. Furthermore, it creates a powerful emotional impact, resonating with viewers and deepening their connection to the characters. This choice, though heartbreaking, significantly advances the overall narrative arc.
Was Matthew’s death in the book Anne of Green Gables?
No, Matthew does not die in the first Anne of Green Gables book. He lives throughout the entire book. Anne with an E takes significant liberties with the original source material, adding darker and more dramatic storylines. This deviation from the source material was a point of contention for some viewers.
How does Matthew’s death change the dynamic at Green Gables?
Matthew’s death fundamentally alters the dynamic at Green Gables. It shifts the focus from Anne’s personal growth to the preservation of the home and the well-being of Marilla. Anne’s decision to stay at Green Gables transforms her role from a child being raised to a caregiver and provider. Green Gables, once a symbol of hope and new beginnings, becomes a place of loss and responsibility.
What are some of the most memorable scenes featuring Matthew?
Some of the most memorable scenes featuring Matthew include his initial meeting with Anne at the train station, his quiet conversations with her, and his unwavering support for her ambitions. His purchase of the puffed sleeves dress for Anne is a particularly touching moment that demonstrates his affection and understanding. These scenes showcase Matthew’s gentle nature and his profound impact on Anne’s life.
Does Matthew’s death lead to any positive changes in Anne’s life?
Despite the immense grief and loss, Matthew’s death ultimately leads to positive changes in Anne’s life. It forces her to grow as a person, to take on new responsibilities, and to appreciate the importance of family and community. Her selfless decision to stay at Green Gables demonstrates her maturity and her deep love for Marilla and Matthew’s memory. While born of tragedy, this event shapes Anne into the remarkable woman she becomes.