No, the 1999 film Coming Soon unequivocally fails the Bechdel Test. Despite featuring prominent female characters, they rarely engage in conversations about anything other than men, particularly their romantic or sexual relationships.
A Deeper Dive into “Coming Soon” and the Bechdel Test
The Bechdel Test, a deceptively simple measure of female representation in film, asks whether a movie contains at least two named female characters who have at least one conversation with each other about something besides a man. While not a definitive gauge of feminism or overall film quality, it serves as a stark indicator of the prevalence of male-centric narratives. Coming Soon, a teen comedy centered on a high school girl who loses her virginity and then loses her memory of it, struggles with this basic representation. While the film features a cast of female friends and family members, their dialogue overwhelmingly revolves around boys, sex, and anxieties about their relationships. This narrow focus ultimately renders the film unable to clear even this low bar.
Why “Coming Soon” Falls Short
The film’s premise, while intending to be humorous and relatable to teenage girls, reinforces stereotypical portrayals of female relationships. The characters are largely defined by their romantic pursuits and their anxieties surrounding them. While friendships are evident, they are often overshadowed by the pervasive focus on boys. Consider the scenes where the protagonist, Stream, interacts with her mother or her best friend, Nell; the conversations consistently steer back to their respective romantic dilemmas, whether it be Stream’s confusion after losing her virginity or Nell’s obsessive crush on a popular boy. This constant redirection to male-centric topics prevents the film from passing the Bechdel Test, even in fleeting moments. The humor, often rooted in sexual innuendo and awkward situations, further contributes to the film’s failure to explore female characters beyond their romantic interests. The film doesn’t offer alternative storylines that feature the women discussing their ambitions, their fears outside of relationships, or their experiences in life beyond the context of their romantic lives.
FAQs: Understanding the Bechdel Test and its Application to “Coming Soon”
FAQ 1: What is the Bechdel Test and what are its criteria?
The Bechdel Test, also known as the Bechdel-Wallace Test, is a simple test that assesses the representation of women in fiction. To pass, a film must meet three criteria:
- Two named female characters: The film needs to have at least two characters identified by name who are women.
- A conversation between them: These two female characters must have at least one conversation with each other.
- The conversation isn’t about a man: The topic of this conversation must be something other than a man or men.
FAQ 2: Why is the Bechdel Test considered important?
The Bechdel Test highlights the disparity in representation of women in media. Its importance lies in its ability to reveal how often female characters are relegated to supporting roles or defined solely by their relationships with men. Failing the test doesn’t necessarily make a film “bad,” but it does suggest a lack of nuanced female representation and a potential reinforcement of gender stereotypes. It’s a conversation starter for examining the wider issue of female representation in media.
FAQ 3: Does “Coming Soon” have two named female characters?
Yes, Coming Soon features numerous named female characters. The protagonist, Stream Heline, her best friend Nell Kellner, and Stream’s mother, Judy Heline, are prominent examples. Therefore, the film satisfies the first requirement of the Bechdel Test.
FAQ 4: Do any of the named female characters in “Coming Soon” have a conversation with each other?
Yes, Stream interacts extensively with both Nell and Judy throughout the film. They engage in numerous conversations, fulfilling the second requirement of the Bechdel Test.
FAQ 5: What are the primary topics of conversation between the female characters in “Coming Soon”?
The conversations between Stream, Nell, and Judy predominantly revolve around dating, sex, and relationships with men. Stream confides in Nell about her experience losing her virginity. Judy discusses her marital problems and dating anxieties. These topics dominate their interactions, preventing the film from satisfying the third criterion.
FAQ 6: Are there any exceptions to the “no conversations about men” rule?
While the Bechdel Test is generally straightforward, some interpretations allow for brief mentions of men if the overall focus of the conversation is on something else. However, in Coming Soon, the conversations consistently and primarily center on men and their role in the female characters’ lives. Even when other topics are broached, they quickly revert to discussions about romantic relationships or sexual experiences.
FAQ 7: Does failing the Bechdel Test automatically mean a film is sexist?
No. Failing the Bechdel Test is not a definitive judgment of a film’s overall quality or its stance on feminism. It simply indicates a lack of representation of women engaging in conversations about non-male-related topics. A film can fail the test and still be well-written, entertaining, and even contain empowering messages. The Bechdel Test is merely one lens through which to analyze gender representation in media.
FAQ 8: Could any scenes in “Coming Soon” be argued as potentially passing the Bechdel Test under a more lenient interpretation?
It is difficult to argue that Coming Soon passes even under a very lenient interpretation. The core themes and conversations heavily revolve around male characters and romantic pursuits, dominating the screen time and character interactions. Any fleeting moments where alternative topics are touched upon are usually brief and inconsequential compared to the overriding focus on relationships with men.
FAQ 9: How does “Coming Soon” compare to other teen comedies of the late 1990s in terms of the Bechdel Test?
Many teen comedies of the late 1990s similarly struggled with the Bechdel Test. The genre often prioritized romantic storylines and male perspectives, leading to a frequent lack of meaningful conversations between female characters about topics unrelated to men. While some films made strides in female representation, Coming Soon aligns with the prevalent trend of prioritizing male-centric narratives.
FAQ 10: Does the film’s focus on sex and relationships excuse its failure to pass the Bechdel Test?
No. While the film’s premise centers on the protagonist’s sexual experiences, this doesn’t absolve it from the need to portray female characters as individuals with interests and concerns beyond their romantic lives. The Bechdel Test encourages filmmakers to explore the multifaceted nature of female characters and their relationships with each other.
FAQ 11: What are some examples of films that pass the Bechdel Test and showcase strong female relationships?
Examples of films that pass the Bechdel Test and feature strong female relationships include Little Women, Hidden Figures, Bridesmaids, and Moana. These films showcase women interacting in meaningful ways about diverse topics, demonstrating a broader range of female representation.
FAQ 12: How can filmmakers improve female representation and increase the chances of passing the Bechdel Test?
Filmmakers can improve female representation by consciously creating well-developed female characters with their own motivations, goals, and narratives independent of male characters. They can also ensure that female characters engage in conversations about diverse topics, reflecting the complexity of women’s lives and experiences. Prioritizing female perspectives and fostering collaboration between female writers, directors, and producers can further contribute to more nuanced and authentic portrayals of women in film. By actively considering the Bechdel Test as one of many measures, filmmakers can contribute to a more equitable and diverse landscape of representation.
