The role of “Bestie” within the American Horror Story universe isn’t about a single character or actress. Instead, it’s a recurring, meta-narrative commentary often embodied by characters offering blunt honesty, comedic relief, and unwavering loyalty, pushing the boundaries of the show’s already outrageous themes. This multifaceted role has been brilliantly executed by a variety of actors across different seasons.
The Concept of “Bestie” in American Horror Story
American Horror Story is known for its shocking narratives, complex characters, and often dark sense of humor. The “Bestie” figure in the show serves several crucial functions: they are often the voice of reason (or unreason), providing a counterpoint to the protagonist’s descent into madness; they offer a darkly comedic perspective on the horrors unfolding; and they provide unwavering support, even when it’s questionable or morally ambiguous. Understanding the “Bestie” isn’t about finding one single answer, but about recognizing a recurring trope.
Defining the “Bestie” Trope
The “Bestie” in AHS often breaks the fourth wall, even if subtly. They say what the audience is thinking, voicing concerns and criticisms of the characters’ choices. They offer unfiltered honesty, even when it’s brutal. Crucially, they are intensely loyal to their friends, often to a fault. Their loyalty frequently leads them into increasingly dangerous situations, adding another layer to the horror. The role also provides much-needed levity, preventing the show from becoming oppressively grim.
Key Characteristics of the “AHS Bestie”
Consider these characteristics when trying to identify the “Bestie” within a season:
- Brutal Honesty: They don’t sugarcoat the truth, even when it hurts.
- Dark Humor: They can find humor in even the most horrific situations.
- Unwavering Loyalty: They stand by their friends, no matter what.
- Sense of Self-Preservation (or Lack Thereof): Their actions can range from strategically cautious to recklessly brave.
- Metanarrative Commentary: They often say what the audience is thinking about the unfolding events.
Notable “Bestie” Performances Throughout the Seasons
While no character is explicitly labeled “Bestie,” several characters embody these traits remarkably well.
Myrtle Snow (Frances Conroy) in Coven and Apocalypse
Myrtle Snow, portrayed by the exceptional Frances Conroy, is a prime example of the “Bestie” archetype. Her unwavering loyalty to Cordelia Goode (Sarah Paulson), coupled with her eccentric personality, sharp wit, and unwavering dedication to her coven, perfectly fits the bill. Her iconic lines and sacrifices solidify her place as a truly unforgettable “Bestie” character. Her fashion sense alone deserves an award. Myrtle’s dry humor and eccentric wisdom offer a counterpoint to the coven’s darker tendencies.
Liz Taylor (Denis O’Hare) in Hotel and Roanoke
Liz Taylor, played by Denis O’Hare, is another standout. As a transgender bartender at the Hotel Cortez, Liz provides a safe haven and confidante to many of the hotel’s inhabitants, particularly The Countess (Lady Gaga). Liz is fiercely loyal and possesses a dry wit that cuts through the drama. Liz is a source of compassion and stability in the chaotic world of the Hotel Cortez.
Beverly Hope (Adina Porter) in Cult
Beverly Hope, expertly portrayed by Adina Porter, offers a darker take on the “Bestie” role. As a news reporter caught up in Kai Anderson’s (Evan Peters) cult, Beverly provides pragmatic support and becomes a key figure in his inner circle. While her motivations are complex and her methods are often questionable, her loyalty, albeit twisted, is undeniable. Beverly’s cynicism and pragmatism are a chilling reflection of the season’s themes.
Others to Consider
While Myrtle, Liz, and Beverly stand out, other characters also exhibit “Bestie” qualities in varying degrees. Some honorable mentions include:
- Nan (Jamie Brewer) in Coven: Her unwavering loyalty to Zoe (Taissa Farmiga).
- Queenie (Gabourey Sidibe) in Coven, Hotel, and Apocalypse: Her pragmatic and supportive nature.
- Madison Montgomery (Emma Roberts) in Coven and Apocalypse: Despite her flaws, her loyalty to herself and her friends is apparent.
FAQs: Diving Deeper into the “Bestie” Phenomenon
FAQ 1: Is there an official “Bestie” character in every season of AHS?
No, there isn’t. The “Bestie” is not a formal character type that appears in every season. Instead, it’s a recurring archetype that certain characters embody, depending on the season’s narrative and themes. Some seasons may have multiple characters who fit the description, while others may have none.
FAQ 2: What makes a character a “Bestie” in AHS compared to just a friend?
The difference lies in the intensity of their loyalty, their unwavering support, and their willingness to engage in morally questionable behavior for their friends. A regular friend might offer advice or support, but a “Bestie” in AHS is often willing to go to extreme lengths, even sacrificing their own well-being, for their friend. They also provide a more brutally honest perspective, often laced with dark humor.
FAQ 3: Does the “Bestie” character always survive the season?
Absolutely not! Survival is rare. In fact, the “Bestie” role often seems to be a death sentence in AHS. Their loyalty and willingness to get involved often put them in harm’s way, making them vulnerable to the season’s various threats. Their deaths are often particularly tragic and emotionally resonant.
FAQ 4: Is the “Bestie” character always a “good” person?
No. The “Bestie” archetype is often morally ambiguous. They might have questionable motives, engage in unethical behavior, or even be actively evil. However, their loyalty to their friend remains unwavering, regardless of their own morality. The complexity of these characters is part of what makes them so compelling.
FAQ 5: Who is the most popular “Bestie” character according to fans?
Myrtle Snow (Frances Conroy) consistently ranks highly in fan polls and discussions about the best AHS characters. Her iconic lines, eccentric personality, and unwavering loyalty to Cordelia have made her a fan favorite. Liz Taylor (Denis O’Hare) is also highly praised for her compassion, wit, and captivating backstory.
FAQ 6: Can a villain be considered a “Bestie” in AHS?
Yes, absolutely. As demonstrated by Beverly Hope in Cult, a villain can certainly embody the “Bestie” archetype. Their loyalty might be twisted or self-serving, but it’s still a defining characteristic. They might support their friend’s evil plans, even if they don’t necessarily agree with them, out of a sense of loyalty or shared purpose.
FAQ 7: How does the “Bestie” character contribute to the overall themes of the show?
The “Bestie” character often serves to explore themes of loyalty, friendship, morality, and the lengths people will go to for those they care about. They can also act as a commentary on the show’s themes, offering a critical perspective on the characters’ actions and the unfolding events.
FAQ 8: Are the “Bestie” characters always LGBTQ+?
No, this isn’t always the case, though many prominent examples, such as Liz Taylor, are. While LGBTQ+ representation has been a consistent strength of AHS, the “Bestie” role itself is not inherently tied to sexual orientation or gender identity. The key is the character’s loyalty, humor, and willingness to stand by their friend.
FAQ 9: How does Ryan Murphy, the show’s creator, utilize the “Bestie” trope?
Ryan Murphy seems to use the “Bestie” trope to add layers of complexity to the narratives. By creating characters that are both loyal and flawed, he challenges viewers to question their own definitions of friendship and morality. The “Bestie” also offers a unique lens through which to view the show’s often shocking and disturbing events.
FAQ 10: Which actress has portrayed the “Bestie” archetype most effectively?
Frances Conroy’s portrayal of Myrtle Snow is widely considered to be the most effective embodiment of the “Bestie” archetype. Her performance is both hilarious and heartbreaking, and her character’s unwavering loyalty to Cordelia is deeply moving. She perfectly balances the comedic and dramatic aspects of the role.
FAQ 11: Can a character transition into a “Bestie” throughout the season?
Yes, a character can definitely evolve into a “Bestie” as the season progresses. Their relationships with other characters deepen, their loyalty is tested, and they might find themselves drawn into the drama in unexpected ways. This evolution can be a compelling part of their character arc.
FAQ 12: Why is the “Bestie” character so appealing to audiences?
The “Bestie” character is appealing because they are often relatable, even in the fantastical world of AHS. They offer a sense of groundedness and humanity amidst the chaos and horror. Their loyalty, humor, and willingness to stand up for their friends resonate with viewers, making them a welcome presence in the show. They are the flawed individuals we root for, even when they are making questionable choices.