“Fishes,” the sixth episode of the second season of The Bear, serves as a harrowing yet deeply insightful origin story for the Berzatto family, showcasing the simmering tensions and underlying trauma that shape the characters we know and love. It’s a chaotic Christmas Eve dinner, a pressure cooker of dysfunctional family dynamics brought vividly to life by a stellar ensemble cast.
The Berzatto Family: A Breakdown of Roles and Relationships
The core of “Fishes” revolves around the Berzatto family, headed, or rather unheaded, by their matriarch, Donna Berzatto. Understanding their individual quirks and relationships is crucial to comprehending the episode’s emotional core.
Donna Berzatto (Jamie Lee Curtis)
Donna, played with unnerving intensity by Jamie Lee Curtis, is the volatile and emotionally fragile mother of Carmy, Michael, and Natalie. Her unpredictable behavior and deep-seated insecurities manifest in obsessive cooking, compulsive cleaning, and a constant need for external validation, ultimately culminating in a breakdown that underscores the family’s fractured foundation. She represents the epicenter of the family’s trauma, a wellspring of both love and deep-seated pain.
Carmy Berzatto (Jeremy Allen White)
A younger Carmy, portrayed by Jeremy Allen White with a slightly less world-weary but equally intense gaze, is already exhibiting signs of the burden of responsibility he will eventually shoulder. In “Fishes,” he’s trying to maintain a sense of normalcy amidst the chaos, hinting at his later decision to escape to the culinary world as a form of self-preservation. The episode shows the seeds of his culinary ambition and his early attempts to bring order to a disordered environment.
Michael “Mikey” Berzatto (Jon Bernthal)
Jon Bernthal reprises his role as Mikey, the charismatic but self-destructive older brother whose erratic behavior sets the stage for much of the episode’s conflict. Mikey is shown as manipulative, attention-seeking, and deeply insecure. This Christmas Eve dinner highlights the toxic cycle of codependency and the unresolved issues that ultimately lead to his tragic demise. He’s the catalyst for the chaos, constantly pushing boundaries and testing the limits of everyone’s patience.
Natalie “Sugar” Berzatto (Abby Elliott)
Natalie, or “Sugar,” played by Abby Elliott, is pregnant and already exhibiting her protective and often exasperated demeanor towards her family. She represents the more grounded and pragmatic side of the Berzattos, constantly trying to mediate the conflict and maintain a semblance of order. This episode showcases the origins of her protective instincts towards Carmy and her attempts to escape the family’s dysfunction by building her own stable life.
The Extended Family and Their Complicated Dynamics
Beyond the immediate Berzatto family, a colorful cast of relatives and significant others adds layers of complexity and amplifies the already heightened tension.
Lee (Bob Odenkirk)
Lee, portrayed by Bob Odenkirk, is Michelle’s (Sarah Paulson) boyfriend. He’s abrasive, confrontational, and serves as a primary antagonist, repeatedly clashing with Mikey. Their volatile relationship showcases the underlying animosity and unresolved resentments within the extended family. His presence adds another layer of fuel to the already burning fire of the Christmas dinner.
Michelle (Sarah Paulson)
Michelle, played by Sarah Paulson, is Carmy and Sugar’s cousin and acts as a voice of reason and support, particularly for Carmy. She attempts to offer him a lifeline, suggesting he come live with her to escape the chaotic environment. Her genuine concern and offers of help highlight the contrasting dynamics within the Berzatto family – a desire for connection amidst the dysfunction.
Uncle Jimmy “Cicero” Kalinowski (Oliver Platt)
Uncle Jimmy, or “Cicero,” played by Oliver Platt, is a family friend and business associate with close ties to Mikey. He embodies the more traditional and perhaps questionable aspects of the family’s past. He carries a quiet authority and demonstrates a willingness to enable Mikey’s bad behavior. He’s a reminder of the financial and social entanglements that bind the Berzattos together.
Pete (Chris Witaske)
Pete, Natalie’s boyfriend (and later husband), played by Chris Witaske, is the affable but somewhat hapless outsider trying to navigate the Berzatto family’s chaotic dynamics. He’s clearly overwhelmed but genuinely wants to be supportive, often finding himself caught in the crossfire. He represents the ideal of a stable and loving partner contrasting sharply with the turmoil within the Berzatto family.
Cousin Michael (Ricky Staffieri)
A younger version of Cousin, played by Ricky Staffieri, demonstrates the roots of his loyalty and affection for Carmy. His eagerness to help and his awkward attempts at conversation highlight the close bond they share despite the overall chaos. He’s a reminder that even within the dysfunctional Berzatto family, genuine connections and affection exist.
FAQs: Delving Deeper into “The Bear’s” Christmas Episode
Here are some frequently asked questions to further explore the nuances and impact of “Fishes”:
-
Why is “Fishes” considered such a pivotal episode in The Bear? “Fishes” provides crucial context for understanding the characters’ motivations and behaviors in the present timeline. It reveals the deep-seated trauma and dysfunction that have shaped their lives, making their struggles and triumphs in the restaurant more relatable and impactful.
-
What is the significance of the name “Fishes”? The title is likely a reference to the overwhelming and chaotic nature of the Berzatto family gathering, akin to being surrounded by a school of frantic fish. It can also symbolize the hidden depths and unspoken emotions simmering beneath the surface of their interactions.
-
What does Donna’s cooking obsession reveal about her character? Donna’s compulsive cooking is a manifestation of her anxiety and need for control. It’s a way for her to express love, but also to mask her own insecurities and fears. The constant preparation and elaborate meals are a distraction from the underlying problems.
-
How does Mikey’s behavior in “Fishes” foreshadow his later actions? Mikey’s manipulative, self-destructive, and attention-seeking behavior in “Fishes” foreshadows his downward spiral and ultimately his suicide. The episode provides insights into his deep-seated insecurities and his inability to cope with the family’s dysfunction.
-
What is the significance of the fight between Lee and Mikey? The fight is a culmination of years of resentment and unresolved conflicts. It highlights the toxic dynamic between them and represents the explosive potential of the Berzatto family’s dysfunction. It also shows how even seemingly minor disagreements can escalate into major blowups.
-
What does Michelle’s offer to Carmy reveal about her relationship with the Berzatto family? Michelle’s offer signifies her genuine concern and compassion for Carmy. It suggests that she recognizes the toxic environment he’s living in and wants to help him escape. It also highlights the existence of healthier family dynamics outside the immediate Berzatto circle.
-
How does Pete’s presence as an outsider highlight the family’s dysfunction? Pete’s discomfort and attempts to navigate the Berzatto family’s chaos underscore the abnormality of their behavior. His awkward interactions serve as a contrast to their ingrained dysfunction, making it even more apparent to the viewer.
-
What are some of the hidden details or Easter eggs in “Fishes”? Some viewers have noted that the specific food Donna prepares represents aspects of each family member’s personality or struggles. The episode is rife with symbolic details that add layers of meaning to the narrative.
-
How does the episode use flashbacks to enhance the storytelling? The flashback format allows viewers to understand the origins of the characters’ present-day struggles. It provides context for their actions and motivations, making them more relatable and empathetic.
-
How does “Fishes” contribute to the overall themes of The Bear? “Fishes” reinforces the show’s themes of family, trauma, and the search for connection. It highlights the ways in which past experiences shape present-day relationships and the challenges of breaking free from dysfunctional patterns.
-
Jamie Lee Curtis’s performance as Donna is highly praised. What makes it so effective? Curtis perfectly embodies Donna’s vulnerability, anxiety, and underlying rage. Her portrayal is both heartbreaking and terrifying, capturing the complexity of a mother struggling with mental health issues.
-
What lessons can viewers take away from “Fishes”? “Fishes” serves as a powerful reminder of the lasting impact of family dynamics and the importance of addressing unresolved trauma. It also highlights the need for empathy, understanding, and seeking help when struggling with mental health issues. The episode, while chaotic, ultimately showcases the power of love and connection, even in the most dysfunctional of families.