The trailer for the 2007 biopic What We Do Is Secret suggests the band Germs, a pioneering punk rock group, was driven by a nihilistic desire for notoriety achieved through deliberate chaos and self-destruction. The reality, however, is far more complex; while chaos certainly reigned, the Germs were fueled by an artistic vision rooted in raw emotion, social alienation, and a desperate yearning for connection expressed through intensely visceral music. They were products of their time, a generation grappling with disillusionment, and their story is a powerful, if tragic, commentary on the cost of artistic expression.
The Germs: A Brief History of Chaos and Creation
Formed in Los Angeles in 1977, the Germs, fronted by the enigmatic Darby Crash, emerged from the burgeoning punk scene with a sound and image as confrontational as their name. Their raw, unpolished music, often deliberately dissonant and chaotic, reflected the societal unease and personal angst of the era. While their career was short-lived – only releasing one studio album, GI – their influence on subsequent generations of punk and alternative artists remains undeniable. Darby Crash’s self-destructive tendencies, fueled by heroin addiction, ultimately led to his premature death in 1980, effectively ending the Germs’ existence. The film What We Do Is Secret attempted to capture the tumultuous journey of the band, focusing on Crash’s volatile personality and the band’s anarchic energy.
Understanding Darby Crash’s Complex Persona
Darby Crash was more than just a punk icon; he was a complex and often contradictory figure. While he cultivated a persona of nihilistic rebellion and embraced provocative behavior, he was also intellectually curious, reading extensively and expressing a deep understanding of social and political issues. This internal conflict – between his artistic aspirations and his self-destructive impulses – is key to understanding his motivations and the Germs’ overall aesthetic. He used the band as an outlet for his inner turmoil, creating music that was both cathartic and confrontational. The film attempts to portray this complexity, but it’s often difficult to fully capture the nuances of such a troubled soul.
The Impact of GI
The Germs’ debut album, GI, produced by Joan Jett, remains a seminal work of punk rock. Its raw energy, confrontational lyrics, and deliberately unpolished sound set it apart from the more commercially oriented punk bands of the time. Tracks like “Lexicon Devil,” “Manimal,” and “What We Do Is Secret” became anthems for a generation of outcasts, expressing a sense of alienation and disillusionment that resonated deeply with young people struggling to find their place in a seemingly indifferent world. The album’s enduring appeal lies in its authenticity; it captured the raw, unfiltered emotions of a band on the edge, pushing the boundaries of musical expression.
Frequently Asked Questions About The Germs and What We Do Is Secret
Here are some frequently asked questions to provide a deeper understanding of The Germs, their legacy, and the film What We Do Is Secret.
FAQ 1: What does the title “What We Do Is Secret” mean?
The title, taken from one of the Germs’ most famous songs, is open to interpretation. It could refer to the subversive nature of their music and their rejection of mainstream values. It also hints at the band’s inner workings and the personal struggles of its members, shielded from public view. Ultimately, it embodies the band’s enigmatic and rebellious spirit, suggesting that their true motivations and creative processes were intentionally obscured.
FAQ 2: How accurate is the film What We Do Is Secret in portraying the Germs?
While the film attempts to capture the essence of the Germs’ story, like all biopics, it takes artistic liberties. Some details are embellished or condensed for dramatic effect. Some accounts from individuals who were close to the band differ from the film’s portrayal, particularly regarding Darby Crash’s personality and the internal dynamics of the group. It’s essential to view the film as an interpretation of events rather than a definitive historical record.
FAQ 3: Who played Darby Crash in What We Do Is Secret?
Shane West played Darby Crash in the film. His performance was generally well-received, with many critics praising his ability to capture Crash’s volatile energy and stage presence. However, some felt he lacked the depth and complexity of the real Darby Crash.
FAQ 4: What happened to the other members of the Germs after Darby Crash’s death?
Pat Smear, the Germs’ guitarist, went on to achieve significant success, first with Nirvana and later with the Foo Fighters. Lorna Doom, the band’s bassist, remained largely out of the public eye after the Germs disbanded. She sadly passed away in 2019. Don Bolles, the drummer, continued to be involved in the music scene, playing in various bands and working as a DJ.
FAQ 5: Why are the Germs considered so influential despite their short career?
The Germs’ influence stems from their raw, uncompromising sound and their unapologetic rejection of mainstream values. They paved the way for subsequent generations of punk and alternative bands, demonstrating that music could be both chaotic and cathartic, a vehicle for expressing anger, frustration, and alienation. Their influence can be heard in bands ranging from hardcore punk groups to grunge and alternative rock acts.
FAQ 6: What is the musical style of the Germs?
The Germs are generally classified as punk rock, but their sound was more abrasive and experimental than many of their contemporaries. Their music often featured dissonant chords, irregular song structures, and Darby Crash’s distinctive, often guttural vocals. Some critics have described their sound as proto-hardcore, foreshadowing the more aggressive and intense styles of punk that would emerge in the 1980s.
FAQ 7: Where can I listen to The Germs’ music?
The Germs’ only studio album, GI, is widely available on streaming services like Spotify, Apple Music, and YouTube Music. Compilations featuring rare tracks and live recordings are also available. Physical copies of GI on vinyl and CD can be found at record stores and online retailers.
FAQ 8: Are there any other documentaries or books about The Germs?
Besides the film What We Do Is Secret, there are several documentaries and books that delve into the history of the Germs. “The Decline of Western Civilization” (1981) includes live footage of the band. Several biographies about Darby Crash, offering different perspectives on his life and legacy, have also been published.
FAQ 9: How did the Germs contribute to the Los Angeles punk scene?
The Germs were central figures in the vibrant and influential Los Angeles punk scene of the late 1970s. They played regularly at iconic venues like the Masque and the Whisky a Go Go, helping to create a community of musicians, artists, and fans who shared a common sense of rebellion and disillusionment. Their music and image were deliberately confrontational, challenging the status quo and inspiring others to express themselves in bold and unconventional ways.
FAQ 10: What was the significance of Darby Crash’s overdose?
Darby Crash’s overdose, which occurred on December 7, 1980, the same day as John Lennon’s murder, became a symbol of the self-destructive tendencies that often plagued the punk rock scene. It highlighted the dangers of drug addiction and the often-tragic consequences of living a life on the edge. His death solidified his status as a punk rock icon, but also served as a cautionary tale about the perils of unchecked excess.
FAQ 11: What were Darby Crash’s influences?
Darby Crash was influenced by a diverse range of artists and thinkers. He was a voracious reader, drawing inspiration from writers like Nietzsche, Baudelaire, and William S. Burroughs. Musically, he was inspired by bands like the Sex Pistols, Iggy Pop and the Stooges, and David Bowie. He also incorporated elements of performance art and theatricality into his stage persona, drawing inspiration from figures like Andy Warhol.
FAQ 12: Is What We Do Is Secret worth watching for fans of punk rock?
Despite its inaccuracies, What We Do Is Secret offers a glimpse into the world of the Germs and the early Los Angeles punk scene. It can be a worthwhile watch for fans of punk rock, particularly those interested in learning more about the band’s history and Darby Crash’s complex personality. However, it’s important to remember that the film is an interpretation, and viewers should seek out other sources to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the Germs’ story.