The episode “Simply the Best” (Season 4, Episode 6) undeniably reigns supreme as the most iconic and impactful episode of Schitt’s Creek, showcasing the series’ unparalleled ability to blend humor, heartfelt emotion, and character development into a perfectly crafted 22 minutes. It’s a masterclass in nuanced storytelling, where David’s genuine vulnerability and Patrick’s unwavering affection culminate in a serenading moment that transcends television and resonates deeply with viewers worldwide.
Why “Simply the Best” Stands Above the Rest
While Schitt’s Creek boasts a plethora of memorable episodes, “Simply the Best” achieves a unique level of resonance. It’s not just about the song; it’s about everything that leads up to and follows that pivotal scene. The episode expertly lays the groundwork, showing David’s initial reluctance and fear of commitment, contrasting it with Patrick’s unwavering and unapologetic love. The car ride to the accountant serves as a microcosm of their relationship: David is anxious and controlling, while Patrick offers calm reassurance and unwavering support.
The episode’s brilliance lies in its authenticity. The characters feel real, their struggles relatable, and their eventual growth inspiring. We see David, a character initially defined by cynicism and self-preservation, slowly opening himself up to love and trust. Patrick, in turn, demonstrates the power of unwavering belief in someone, even when they doubt themselves.
Furthermore, the episode’s humor is perfectly balanced with its emotional core. The jokes are sharp and witty, providing moments of levity without undermining the underlying sincerity. From Moira’s cryptic advice on love to Johnny’s attempts to understand David’s relationship, the supporting characters provide comedic relief while simultaneously contributing to the overall narrative.
The use of Tina Turner’s “The Best” is nothing short of genius. It’s not simply a song; it’s a statement of love and acceptance that perfectly encapsulates Patrick’s feelings for David. The acoustic rendition adds a layer of intimacy and vulnerability, making the moment all the more impactful. This scene has become a cultural touchstone, often cited as one of the most romantic and moving moments in television history.
Finally, the episode’s legacy speaks for itself. “Simply the Best” continues to generate discussions, analyses, and countless fan tributes. Its enduring popularity is a testament to its exceptional writing, acting, and overall emotional impact. It’s an episode that stays with you long after the credits roll, reminding you of the power of love, acceptance, and finding the best in yourself and others.
Frequently Asked Questions About “Simply the Best”
We address common questions about this beloved Schitt’s Creek episode to provide further insight and appreciation.
1. Why is the song choice “The Best” so significant?
The song “The Best,” famously performed by Tina Turner, transcends its musicality and becomes a powerful symbol of unwavering love and acceptance. Patrick’s choice is not arbitrary; it directly mirrors his perception of David. He sees past David’s cynicism and defenses to the genuine, caring person underneath. The song’s lyrics resonate deeply with their relationship, highlighting David’s unique qualities and Patrick’s unwavering belief in him. It’s a declaration of love that speaks louder than any words.
2. How does David’s character arc contribute to the impact of the episode?
David’s character arc is fundamental to the episode’s emotional depth. Throughout the series, David undergoes significant transformation, moving from a self-centered and guarded individual to someone capable of genuine connection and vulnerability. “Simply the Best” marks a crucial turning point in this journey. His initial hesitation and fear of commitment provide a stark contrast to Patrick’s openness and affection, highlighting the progress David has made. The episode demonstrates his willingness to embrace vulnerability and open himself up to love, making Patrick’s gesture all the more meaningful.
3. What is the significance of the accountant scene before the serenade?
The seemingly mundane trip to the accountant is crucial to understanding David and Patrick’s relationship dynamics. It showcases David’s controlling tendencies and anxieties about financial stability, which stem from his past experiences. Patrick, on the other hand, provides a steadying presence, offering reassurance and support. This scene highlights the contrasting personalities and how they complement each other, demonstrating the strength of their bond even in seemingly ordinary situations.
4. How does the humor in the episode enhance, rather than detract from, the emotional moments?
The humor in “Simply the Best” is cleverly interwoven with the emotional narrative, providing moments of levity without undermining the underlying sincerity. Moira’s eccentric pronouncements and Johnny’s bewildered attempts to understand David’s relationship serve as comedic relief, preventing the episode from becoming overly saccharine. The humor also underscores the family dynamic and the Rose family’s unique way of navigating life’s challenges. It allows viewers to connect with the characters on a deeper level and appreciate their individual quirks.
5. Why is the acoustic version of “The Best” so effective?
The stripped-down acoustic rendition of “The Best” amplifies the intimacy and vulnerability of the moment. Without the bombastic production of the original, Patrick’s voice and guitar become the sole focus, emphasizing the raw emotion and sincerity of his gesture. It’s a deeply personal and heartfelt performance that resonates with David on a profound level. The acoustic version strips away any pretense, revealing the pure, unadulterated love that Patrick feels for David.
6. What impact did this episode have on the LGBTQ+ community?
“Simply the Best” had a profound and positive impact on the LGBTQ+ community. It presented a rare and authentic portrayal of a same-sex relationship that was free from tired tropes and stereotypes. David and Patrick’s relationship was portrayed with nuance, humor, and genuine affection, offering a refreshing and relatable representation for LGBTQ+ viewers. The episode’s widespread popularity helped normalize same-sex relationships and contributed to a greater understanding and acceptance of LGBTQ+ individuals. It became a symbol of hope and affirmation for many.
7. How does “Simply the Best” compare to other memorable episodes of Schitt’s Creek?
While Schitt’s Creek has many outstanding episodes, “Simply the Best” stands out for its unparalleled combination of humor, heart, and character development. Episodes like “The Incident” and “The Dress” are hilarious, but they don’t achieve the same emotional depth. “The Wedding,” while heartwarming, builds upon the foundation laid by “Simply the Best.” This episode serves as a pivotal turning point for David’s character and his relationship with Patrick, setting the stage for their eventual marriage.
8. What are some hidden details or Easter eggs that viewers might miss on first viewing?
A subtle detail is the growing comfort David displays in physical touch with Patrick leading up to the serenade. Also, pay attention to the background music throughout the episode, often subtly reflecting the emotional tone of the scene. Furthermore, revisit earlier episodes to appreciate the deliberate seeding of David’s past insecurities and how they are addressed in “Simply the Best“.
9. How did the actors, Dan Levy and Noah Reid, prepare for this episode?
Both Dan Levy and Noah Reid have spoken extensively about the care and attention they put into portraying David and Patrick’s relationship authentically. They emphasized the importance of understanding their characters’ motivations and vulnerabilities. Reid, in particular, practiced the guitar and worked on his vocal performance to ensure the serenade felt genuine and heartfelt. Their dedication and commitment to their roles are evident in the episode’s emotional impact.
10. What makes this episode rewatchable?
“Simply the Best” is endlessly rewatchable because of its perfect blend of humor, heart, and emotional payoff. Each viewing reveals new layers of nuance and appreciation for the characters and their relationships. The feel-good atmosphere and the satisfying resolution make it a comforting and uplifting experience. Viewers often return to this episode for its ability to evoke strong emotions and remind them of the power of love and acceptance.
11. What role does the town of Schitt’s Creek play in the episode’s success?
The town of Schitt’s Creek, with its quirky residents and unpretentious atmosphere, serves as the perfect backdrop for David and Patrick’s relationship to blossom. The town’s accepting and supportive environment allows David to shed his defenses and embrace vulnerability. The contrast between the Rose family’s initial disdain for Schitt’s Creek and their eventual embrace of its community underscores the transformative power of human connection.
12. What is the overall message or takeaway from “Simply the Best”?
The overall message of “Simply the Best” is that love can conquer all, even fear and insecurity. It demonstrates the transformative power of acceptance, vulnerability, and unwavering belief in someone. The episode reminds viewers that true love is not about perfection, but about embracing each other’s flaws and celebrating their unique qualities. It’s a message of hope and affirmation that resonates with audiences of all backgrounds.