Sherry Pie was disqualified from RuPaul’s Drag Race Season 12 after the episodes had already been filmed, but before the season finale aired. Therefore, Sherry Pie does not technically leave in a specific episode, but rather is edited out of future episodes where possible after episode 7.
The Unfolding Scandal and Its Impact
The news surrounding Sherry Pie, whose real name is Joey Gugliemelli, broke between the airing of episodes 5 and 6 of Season 12. Allegations of catfishing and sexual misconduct surfaced, involving numerous individuals who accused Gugliemelli of deceptive and predatory behavior under the guise of casting calls for theatre and film productions.
The scale and nature of the allegations were deeply disturbing, prompting a swift and decisive response from VH1 and World of Wonder, the producers of RuPaul’s Drag Race. While the episodes featuring Sherry Pie had already been filmed and largely edited, the producers took unprecedented steps to minimize Gugliemelli’s presence in the remainder of the season.
This involved significantly reducing Sherry Pie’s screen time in subsequent episodes, editing out her commentary where feasible, and refocusing the narrative to highlight the other queens. The aim was to acknowledge the situation without unduly celebrating or glorifying Gugliemelli’s participation, ensuring that the victims of the alleged misconduct were respected.
The decision to air Season 12 at all, even with the editing, was debated within the RuPaul’s Drag Race fanbase. Some felt that completely shelving the season would have been a more appropriate response. However, the producers ultimately decided to proceed, arguing that the remaining queens deserved to have their hard work and talent showcased.
The aftermath of the scandal dramatically changed the landscape of Season 12. The competition felt inherently different, shadowed by the off-screen events. While the other queens continued to compete fiercely, the emotional weight of the situation was palpable. The eventual winner of the season, Jaida Essence Hall, emerged as a true champion, navigating the difficult circumstances with grace, talent, and resilience.
Sherry Pie’s Presence and Impact on Subsequent Episodes
While Sherry Pie’s elimination was never explicitly aired, her presence was undeniably diminished. Here’s a breakdown:
- Episode 8 Onward: Her screen time was significantly reduced, with challenges and runway presentations edited to minimize her focus. Judges’ critiques were also edited where possible to remove specific mentions of her.
- Untucked: Sherry Pie’s appearances in Untucked episodes were also severely cut, limiting her interactions with the other queens.
- Season Finale: Sherry Pie was excluded from the virtual season finale, ensuring that she did not participate in the final crowning.
The editing was often noticeable, with abrupt cuts and shifts in focus. However, most viewers understood the reason for these changes and appreciated the efforts made to address the situation.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
H3 What specific allegations were made against Sherry Pie?
The allegations against Sherry Pie involved numerous instances of catfishing and sexual misconduct. Victims reported being contacted online with promises of acting and theatre roles, often involving explicit audition requests. Under the guise of these professional opportunities, Gugliemelli allegedly pressured victims into sending inappropriate photos and videos, sometimes leading to exploitative and abusive situations.
H3 Why wasn’t Sherry Pie completely removed from Season 12?
Completely removing Sherry Pie would have been logistically challenging and potentially unfair to the other contestants. The episodes had already been filmed and largely edited. To re-edit the entire season would have been incredibly time-consuming and expensive, and would have impacted the screen time and narratives of the other queens who had worked equally hard. The compromise was to minimize her presence as much as possible.
H3 Did Sherry Pie apologize for her actions?
Sherry Pie released an initial apology on social media which was widely criticized for being insincere and deflective. It was perceived as minimizing her actions and focusing on her own well-being rather than acknowledging the harm caused to her victims. Later, she issued a more detailed apology that was still met with mixed reactions.
H3 How did the other queens react to the scandal?
The other queens of Season 12 expressed a range of emotions, including shock, anger, and disappointment. They publicly condemned Sherry Pie’s actions and voiced their support for the victims. Many felt betrayed and disheartened by the situation. They balanced the need to acknowledge the seriousness of the allegations with their desire to celebrate their own achievements.
H3 Did the scandal affect the show’s ratings?
Interestingly, the scandal did not significantly decrease the show’s ratings. In fact, some argue that it drew more attention to the season, although likely for the wrong reasons. Viewers were curious to see how the producers would handle the situation and how the other queens would respond.
H3 What happened to Sherry Pie’s winnings?
Sherry Pie was disqualified from winning the season and therefore did not receive any prize money or the crown. The funds that would have been allocated to her were presumably reallocated to other production needs or future seasons.
H3 Was there any legal action taken against Sherry Pie?
Yes, at least one civil lawsuit was filed against Sherry Pie. Several of her victims have also spoken publicly about considering legal action, and more may have been settled out of court.
H3 What measures has RuPaul’s Drag Race taken to prevent similar incidents in the future?
Following the Sherry Pie scandal, RuPaul’s Drag Race implemented stricter background checks and psychological evaluations for potential contestants. The show also introduced mandatory sensitivity training for all participants and production staff, emphasizing ethical behavior and respect for boundaries.
H3 What is Sherry Pie doing now?
After a period of relative silence, Sherry Pie has attempted to revive her career by performing in local venues and promoting her online presence. These attempts have often been met with significant backlash and protests, highlighting the lasting impact of her actions.
H3 How can I support the victims of Sherry Pie’s alleged misconduct?
Several organizations support survivors of sexual abuse and exploitation. Donating to or volunteering with such organizations is a valuable way to offer support. Furthermore, amplifying the voices of survivors and advocating for systemic change can help prevent similar incidents from occurring. Online groups like [provide an example, but ensure it’s a reputable and established organization] offer resources and support for survivors.
H3 Is Season 12 considered a “tainted” season?
Some viewers consider Season 12 to be “tainted” due to the Sherry Pie scandal, while others argue that the resilience and talent of the remaining queens ultimately defined the season. It remains a complex and controversial chapter in RuPaul’s Drag Race history, prompting important conversations about accountability, redemption, and the impact of online behavior.
H3 Will Sherry Pie ever return to RuPaul’s Drag Race?
Given the severity of the allegations and the widespread condemnation of her actions, it is highly unlikely that Sherry Pie will ever return to RuPaul’s Drag Race. Her actions have damaged her reputation beyond repair within the drag community and the broader entertainment industry. The producers of the show have a responsibility to protect their contestants and viewers and to uphold ethical standards. Therefore, a return seems impossible.