Rick Grimes ultimately does not slit Negan’s neck in The Walking Dead. While it appears he’s about to deliver the fatal blow, and audiences brace themselves for Negan’s death, Rick instead opts to severely wound him in Season 8, Episode 16, “Wrath”.
The Moment of Decision: Episode 816, “Wrath”
In the climax of the Savior War, after a brutal battle and countless losses on both sides, Rick finally confronts Negan. He has Negan pinned, seemingly moments away from achieving his long-sought revenge. He raises Lucille, Negan’s signature weapon, to strike the killing blow. However, at the last second, Rick makes a pivotal decision: instead of ending Negan’s life, he slashes his throat just enough to incapacitate him. This act, while shocking to many characters and viewers, is the culmination of Rick’s burgeoning philosophy shift, influenced by Carl’s dying wish for a better future. He chooses to end the cycle of violence, opting for a new era of community-building and forgiveness, however difficult that path may be.
Why Didn’t Rick Kill Negan?
Rick’s decision was driven by several converging factors:
-
Carl’s Legacy: Carl’s dying plea for peace and a better future for everyone, including former enemies, profoundly impacted Rick. He realized that endless revenge would only perpetuate the cycle of violence and prevent true societal rebuilding. Carl envisioned a future where everyone, even Negan, could contribute to a more harmonious world.
-
A Shift in Philosophy: While initially consumed by vengeance, Rick gradually began to understand that killing Negan wouldn’t solve the underlying problems. True victory lay in creating a sustainable and just society where violence wasn’t the primary solution.
-
Ending the War, Not Just the Enemy: Rick realized that killing Negan would only make him a martyr to his followers. By keeping Negan alive and imprisoned, he could effectively dismantle the Saviors’ ideology and offer them a chance to join the new, unified communities.
-
The Power of Mercy: Ultimately, Rick demonstrated mercy, an act that he believed was essential for rebuilding civilization. It was a bold move that showed true leadership and set the stage for a future defined by cooperation and forgiveness, not just survival.
The Aftermath: Negan’s Imprisonment
Following the throat-slashing, Negan is healed and imprisoned in Alexandria. This confinement becomes a key part of the narrative moving forward, allowing for complex interactions between Negan and other characters, including Rick’s successor, Judith Grimes. His presence serves as a constant reminder of the past conflict and the possibility of redemption. While imprisoned, Negan reflects on his actions and, surprisingly, begins to evolve as a character. He often offers insightful, if sometimes cynical, observations, and occasionally even proves to be a valuable ally, particularly when dealing with new threats.
FAQs: Diving Deeper into Rick and Negan’s Complex Relationship
Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the circumstances surrounding Rick’s decision and its impact:
Why was Rick so fixated on killing Negan to begin with?
Rick’s initial desire to kill Negan stemmed from the Saviors’ brutal and oppressive regime. Negan’s sadistic acts, including the murder of Abraham and Glenn, served as a catalyst for Rick’s initial thirst for vengeance. This was further fueled by Negan’s systematic exploitation of other communities, forcing them to provide supplies and resources under threat of violence. The death of Glenn, in particular, became a deeply personal wound for Rick, driving his initial determination to eliminate Negan as a threat.
What specific event made Rick change his mind about killing Negan?
While Carl’s death was pivotal, there wasn’t one single event that completely changed Rick’s mind. It was a gradual process fueled by various experiences and interactions, including conversations with Michonne and the evolving needs of the growing communities. Carl’s last words, emphasizing the need for a better future where everyone can live in peace, were the final push Rick needed to prioritize forgiveness over revenge. He realized that continuing the cycle of violence would ultimately undermine the very society he was trying to build.
How did the other characters react to Rick’s decision to spare Negan?
The reaction was mixed. Many characters, particularly Maggie, were outraged that Rick chose to spare Negan after everything he had done. Some felt betrayed, believing that Rick had abandoned their right to justice. Others, like Michonne, understood and supported Rick’s vision for a more peaceful future. Maggie’s resentment towards Negan became a recurring theme, leading to conflicts and challenging the stability of the communities.
Did Negan ever escape from his prison cell?
Yes, Negan eventually escaped from Alexandria’s prison. However, he didn’t immediately revert to his old ways. His escape was driven by a desire to prove himself and find a place in the new world, even if it meant leaving Alexandria. He ultimately returns to Alexandria, showcasing a degree of personal growth and a commitment to the new community.
Did Rick ever regret not killing Negan?
The series never explicitly shows Rick regretting his decision. While he undoubtedly faced challenges and criticisms as a result, he remained steadfast in his belief that sparing Negan was the right choice for the long-term survival and well-being of the communities. Rick’s conviction in his decision demonstrated his strong leadership and unwavering commitment to his vision for the future.
What happened to Negan after Rick Grimes left the show?
Following Rick’s disappearance, Negan continued to reside in Alexandria, albeit with a degree of cautious acceptance from the community. He even formed a unique bond with Judith Grimes, who saw a different side of him than most others. Negan eventually left Alexandria to find his own path, ultimately establishing a life for himself and even starting a family.
How did Negan’s imprisonment contribute to the storyline of The Walking Dead?
Negan’s imprisonment created numerous opportunities for character development and complex interactions. His presence forced other characters to confront their own beliefs about justice, forgiveness, and redemption. It also introduced a morally ambiguous element into the narrative, challenging the audience to consider the complexities of human nature and the consequences of violence. Negan’s transformation from a villain to a more nuanced character was a significant contribution to the series’ overall arc.
Why was Negan such a popular villain despite his horrific actions?
Negan’s popularity stemmed from Jeffrey Dean Morgan’s compelling performance and the character’s unique blend of charisma and brutality. He was a complex villain with a distinct personality and a twisted sense of humor, making him both terrifying and strangely captivating. His witty remarks and unpredictable behavior made him a memorable and unforgettable antagonist.
What does Negan’s arc say about redemption and forgiveness in a post-apocalyptic world?
Negan’s arc highlights the possibility of redemption, even for those who have committed terrible acts. It suggests that people are capable of change and that forgiveness, while difficult, can be a powerful force for healing and reconciliation. His story underscores the importance of giving people second chances and recognizing the potential for growth, even in the darkest of times.
How did Lucille, Negan’s bat, become such an iconic symbol of The Walking Dead?
Lucille, Negan’s barbed-wire-covered baseball bat, became an iconic symbol due to its association with his brutal reign and the violent deaths of beloved characters. It represented his power, his ruthlessness, and the devastating impact he had on the lives of Rick and his group. Lucille was a tangible representation of Negan’s cruelty and a constant reminder of the horrors of the Savior War.
Did Negan ever express remorse for his actions?
Over time, Negan showed signs of genuine remorse for his past actions, particularly the murder of Glenn. While he never fully absolved himself of responsibility, he demonstrated an understanding of the pain he had caused and a desire to make amends, albeit in his own flawed way. His expressions of remorse, however, were often met with skepticism and distrust, reflecting the deep wounds he had inflicted.
How did Rick’s decision to spare Negan shape the future of the communities in The Walking Dead?
Rick’s decision to spare Negan ultimately paved the way for a more unified and cooperative future for the communities. While it initially caused conflict and division, it eventually led to a greater understanding of the importance of forgiveness, empathy, and working together towards a common goal. It set a precedent for resolving conflicts through diplomacy and collaboration, rather than resorting to violence.
By understanding Rick’s motivations and the subsequent events, we gain a deeper appreciation for the complex themes of The Walking Dead and the enduring impact of Rick’s monumental choice. The series wasn’t just about surviving zombies; it was about surviving ourselves.