Eren Yeager’s transformation from determined Scout to seemingly ruthless antagonist is a gradual process, but the seeds of his perceived “evil” truly take root during and after the Marley arc, specifically beginning in Season 4, Episode 5, “Declaration of War.” While this isn’t a singular, definitive turning point witnessed in one isolated scene, this episode, coupled with the subsequent events of the arc, showcases a significant shift in Eren’s motivations and actions, leading many to consider this the moment he begins his descent.
Unraveling Eren’s Complex Character
Eren’s character arc is perhaps one of the most debated aspects of Attack on Titan. Labeling him simply as “evil” is a gross oversimplification, as his actions are driven by a complex mix of inherited memories, trauma, strategic calculation, and a desperate desire to protect his people. Understanding the nuances of his character is crucial to appreciating the tragedy of his journey.
The Burden of the Attack Titan
Eren inheriting the Attack Titan and, later, the Founding Titan comes with immense power and, more importantly, a flood of past memories. These memories, particularly those of Eren Kruger and Grisha Yeager, heavily influence his understanding of the world and the future. He’s not just acting on his own desires; he’s burdened by the desires and perspectives of those who came before him. This inherited perspective significantly shapes his choices.
The Trauma of the Past
Eren’s childhood was marred by witnessing his mother’s death and the constant threat of Titans. He experiences immense trauma, fueling his initial rage and desire for revenge. While this rage initially seems righteous, it gradually morphs into something darker and more destructive as he gains more power and knowledge. The cycle of violence becomes ingrained in his being.
Strategic Calculation vs. Morality
As Eren matures, he begins to understand the political complexities of the world and the limitations of simple solutions. He starts viewing events from a strategic perspective, making decisions that often conflict with conventional morality. He weighs the lives of his friends against the potential freedom of Eldia, leading to choices that are ethically questionable, if not outright “evil” in the eyes of many. This utilitarian approach, though arguably necessary, casts a dark shadow on his actions.
Examining the Key Episodes
While “Declaration of War” is a pivotal point, understanding Eren’s transformation requires looking at other episodes as well.
“Declaration of War” (Season 4, Episode 5)
This episode marks a stark departure from the Eren we previously knew. He infiltrates Marley, manipulates Reiner, and initiates the attack on Liberio. His cold demeanor and calculated actions, particularly his willingness to endanger civilians, are unsettling. The shock value of this episode is undeniable, solidifying the idea that Eren is no longer the naive idealist he once was.
“Assault” (Season 4, Episode 6)
Following the declaration of war, Eren’s relentless pursuit of his goals, regardless of the cost, is further emphasized. The devastation caused by his attack and the callous disregard for collateral damage solidify the perception of him as a villain. This episode showcases the brutality he’s willing to unleash.
“From You, 2,000 Years Ago” (Season 4, Episode 28)
This is perhaps the most controversial episode concerning Eren’s character. Here, we delve into Eren’s manipulation of his father, Grisha, and his manipulation of Ymir. The revelations surrounding his influence over past events suggest a level of calculated manipulation that many find unforgivable.
FAQs About Eren’s Transformation
Here are some frequently asked questions to help further clarify Eren’s complex journey:
1. Was Eren always destined to become “evil”?
No. Eren’s character is shaped by his experiences and the burden of the Titans. The memories he inherits and the trauma he endures contribute to his transformation. He isn’t inherently “evil” but rather a product of his circumstances.
2. Does Eren have any remorse for his actions?
This is heavily debated. While he displays moments of internal conflict and regret, his commitment to his goals often overrides his emotions. The ending of the manga and anime offer contrasting interpretations of his internal state, leaving room for ambiguity.
3. What were Eren’s motivations for the Rumbling?
Eren believed that the Rumbling, the unleashing of the Wall Titans, was the only way to secure the freedom of Paradis Island and eliminate the threat of Marley and the rest of the world. He saw it as a necessary evil to protect his people.
4. Did Eren have other options besides the Rumbling?
This is a central point of contention. Some argue that Eren could have pursued peaceful negotiations or alternative solutions. However, Eren believed that these options were insufficient and that the world would never truly accept the Eldians.
5. How did Mikasa and Armin react to Eren’s actions?
Mikasa and Armin struggled immensely with Eren’s transformation. They desperately tried to understand his motivations and find a way to stop him without resorting to violence. Their unwavering loyalty and friendship were constantly tested by Eren’s choices.
6. Was Eren brainwashed by Zeke or the Founding Titan?
While Zeke influenced Eren to some extent, the ultimate decisions were Eren’s own. The Founding Titan granted him immense power, but it did not control his mind. He used its power to enact his own vision of freedom.
7. What is the significance of Eren’s manipulation of Grisha?
Eren’s manipulation of Grisha highlights the deterministic nature of fate in Attack on Titan. It suggests that Eren was destined to follow a specific path, even influencing events in the past to ensure his future.
8. Is there any redemption for Eren at the end of the series?
Whether Eren is ultimately redeemed is a matter of personal interpretation. While he achieved his goal of ending the cycle of hatred to some extent, his actions caused immense suffering and destruction.
9. How does Eren’s character relate to themes of freedom and determinism?
Eren’s character embodies the complex interplay between freedom and determinism. He strives for freedom but is also bound by the inherited memories and the future he has witnessed. This tension is central to the narrative of Attack on Titan.
10. Why is Eren’s transformation considered so controversial among fans?
Eren’s transformation challenges the traditional notion of a hero. His actions are morally ambiguous and often reprehensible, forcing viewers to question their own values and beliefs.
11. What impact did Eren’s choices have on the future of Paradis Island?
Eren’s actions, while devastating, ultimately led to a period of peace and stability on Paradis Island. However, the long-term consequences of his choices remain uncertain.
12. What is the ultimate message that Attack on Titan conveys through Eren’s story?
Attack on Titan, through Eren’s story, explores the cyclical nature of violence, the complexities of freedom, and the dangers of unchecked power. It challenges viewers to confront difficult questions about morality, responsibility, and the human condition.
Conclusion: A Tragic Anti-Hero
Eren Yeager’s descent into perceived “evil” is not a sudden event but a gradual process fueled by trauma, inherited memories, and a desperate desire for freedom. While “Declaration of War” marks a significant turning point, understanding his transformation requires a comprehensive examination of his actions, motivations, and the overarching themes of Attack on Titan. Ultimately, Eren is a tragic anti-hero whose story serves as a cautionary tale about the consequences of unchecked power and the enduring cycle of hatred. His character remains a complex and debated figure, prompting viewers to grapple with uncomfortable truths about the nature of good and evil.