The answer depends on which adaptation of Roald Dahl’s classic tale you’re referring to. The 1990 film, The Witches, directed by Nicolas Roeg, has a runtime of approximately 91 minutes (1 hour and 31 minutes), while the 2020 version, directed by Robert Zemeckis, clocks in at roughly 104 minutes (1 hour and 44 minutes). Both films offer different interpretations of the beloved story, each with its own pacing and storytelling choices.
Dissecting the Run Times: 1990 vs. 2020
Understanding the duration of each Witches adaptation allows viewers to plan their viewing experience and appreciate the differing approaches taken by the filmmakers. The 1990 version, known for its darker tone and iconic practical effects, is a tightly paced thrill ride. The 2020 film, aiming for a more family-friendly approach with updated visuals, allows more time for character development and world-building.
Runtime Breakdown: 1990’s The Witches
The 1990 film’s brevity contributes to its sense of urgency and relentless tension. From the opening moments of Grandmamma Helga’s cautionary tales to the climactic confrontation with the Grand High Witch, the narrative maintains a brisk pace. This compact runtime focuses on the core elements of the story: Luke’s transformation, his grandmother’s unwavering support, and the witches’ sinister plot to eliminate children.
Runtime Breakdown: 2020’s The Witches
The 2020 adaptation, with its longer runtime, offers a more expansive narrative. This extra time is utilized to flesh out the relationship between Charlie (renamed from Luke) and his Grandma (instead of Grandmamma), explore the setting of 1960s Alabama, and showcase more elaborate visual effects. While some critics argue the longer runtime contributes to pacing issues, others appreciate the added depth and character nuances.
Frequently Asked Questions About The Witches Movies
To further illuminate the subject of The Witches films and their runtimes, here are 12 frequently asked questions:
FAQ 1: Is the 1990 Witches movie considered scary for children?
The 1990 Witches film is often regarded as moderately scary for children. The Grand High Witch’s transformation, Anjelica Huston’s performance, and the overall dark tone can be unsettling for younger viewers. Parental guidance is advised, especially for children under the age of eight.
FAQ 2: Does the 2020 Witches movie follow the book more closely than the 1990 version?
While both films are based on Roald Dahl’s The Witches, neither is a completely faithful adaptation. The 2020 version makes significant changes to the setting and characters, diverging more substantially from the source material than the 1990 film, which adheres closer to the original plot points, though it too takes liberties.
FAQ 3: Which version of The Witches is considered the superior adaptation?
This is subjective and depends on personal preference. Many critics and fans favor the 1990 version for its darker tone, impressive practical effects, and faithful, albeit slightly altered, adaptation of Dahl’s story. However, some appreciate the 2020 version’s updated visuals and attempt to modernize the narrative.
FAQ 4: Where can I watch the 1990 Witches movie online?
The 1990 Witches movie is typically available for streaming on platforms like HBO Max (now Max), Amazon Prime Video (rental or purchase), and Apple TV (rental or purchase). Availability may vary depending on your region.
FAQ 5: Where can I watch the 2020 Witches movie online?
The 2020 Witches movie is typically available for streaming on HBO Max (now Max), Amazon Prime Video (rental or purchase), and Apple TV (rental or purchase). Like the 1990 film, availability may be subject to regional restrictions.
FAQ 6: Does either movie have a post-credits scene?
Neither the 1990 nor the 2020 adaptation of The Witches features a post-credits scene. Therefore, viewers don’t need to wait until the credits have fully rolled.
FAQ 7: Who plays the Grand High Witch in each movie?
In the 1990 Witches movie, the Grand High Witch is played by the iconic Anjelica Huston. In the 2020 version, the role is taken on by Anne Hathaway.
FAQ 8: Are there significant differences in the endings of the two movies?
Yes, there are differences. The 1990 film maintains the book’s bittersweet ending, where Luke remains a mouse but embraces his new reality with his grandmother. The 2020 version alters the ending, allowing the children transformed into mice to be turned back into humans, resulting in a more conventionally happy ending.
FAQ 9: What age is The Witches book appropriate for?
Roald Dahl’s The Witches is generally considered appropriate for children aged 8-12. The book contains themes of danger, transformation, and death, so parental discretion is advised for younger readers.
FAQ 10: Did Roald Dahl approve of the 1990 movie?
Roald Dahl reportedly disliked the ending of the 1990 film, as it deviated from his original ending in the book. He found the altered, more upbeat conclusion to be a betrayal of his vision.
FAQ 11: What are some common criticisms of the 2020 Witches movie?
Common criticisms of the 2020 Witches movie include accusations of racial insensitivity in the depiction of the witches’ hands (some viewers felt it resembled limb difference stereotypes), a weaker narrative compared to the 1990 version, and a lack of genuine scares.
FAQ 12: Are there any plans for a sequel or remake of either Witches movie?
As of now, there are no publicly announced plans for a sequel or remake of either the 1990 or 2020 Witches movies. While the story remains popular, and Hollywood’s penchant for reboots is ever-present, nothing is currently in development.
Conclusion: Choosing Your Witches Experience
Ultimately, the preferred version of The Witches is a matter of personal taste. Whether you prefer the darkly whimsical charm of the 1990 adaptation with its 91-minute runtime or the more visually ambitious and slightly longer 2020 version at 104 minutes, both films offer a unique take on Roald Dahl’s timeless tale. By understanding the runtime differences and nuances of each adaptation, viewers can make an informed decision and enjoy the Witches experience that best suits their preferences.