Indecent Proposal concludes with David Murphy winning back his wife, Diana, after a year of separation instigated by a million-dollar offer from billionaire John Gage. The film ultimately affirms the strength of their original love and commitment over material temptations, leaving Gage to recognize his failed attempt to buy Diana’s affection.
The Reunion: Love’s Triumphant Return
The ending of Indecent Proposal isn’t simply about Diana returning to David; it’s a culmination of a year of emotional and personal growth for both characters. Following the acceptance of John Gage’s infamous million-dollar offer, Diana and David struggle to reconcile their values and their relationship. Diana feels guilt and shame, while David grapples with resentment and a damaged ego.
The separation year allows them both to confront their individual flaws and reassess what truly matters. David focuses on his architecture career, achieving success that validates his self-worth outside of his relationship with Diana. Diana, meanwhile, confronts her own desires and realizes that material wealth cannot replace genuine love and connection.
The final scene takes place in Las Vegas, where it all began. Diana seeks out David, not seeking his forgiveness, but offering him a second chance. She wins a substantial amount of money at a craps table and uses it to buy a single chip, offering it to David. He understands the symbolic significance: she doesn’t need Gage’s money, nor does she value it above him. He asks her the key question he posed earlier in the movie – “What if you had to do it again?” – and her heartfelt response (“I wouldn’t.”) seals their reconciliation. They leave Las Vegas together, suggesting a renewed commitment and a deeper understanding of their love.
John Gage’s Acceptance and Reflection
John Gage’s role in the ending is crucial. He doesn’t fight for Diana; instead, he recognizes that he cannot buy genuine love. He witnesses Diana’s continued affection for David, even after a year apart and despite his own persistent presence in her life.
Gage’s final act of leaving them alone, accompanied by a subtle but poignant display of respect, shows his acceptance of defeat. He understands that money can’t buy what David and Diana already share: a genuine emotional connection and a shared history. He may have disrupted their lives, but he ultimately failed to destroy their bond. The ending subtly suggests Gage may have learned something valuable about the limitations of wealth and the importance of authentic relationships.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Indecent Proposal‘s Ending
What specific event triggers Diana’s decision to return to David?
While there isn’t one single event, it’s a gradual realization fueled by her own reflection and the observation of David’s success and continued feelings for her. The Las Vegas setting, a reminder of their initial offer and the subsequent pain, serves as a catalyst. Seeing David, who has rebuilt his life and seemingly moved on, compels her to actively pursue reconciliation.
Does John Gage confess his feelings for Diana at the end?
Not explicitly. There’s no dramatic declaration of love. However, his actions throughout the film, particularly his repeated attempts to be close to Diana and his final, unspoken acceptance, strongly imply a deep affection that goes beyond mere attraction or conquest.
Why does Diana give David the chip she won?
The chip represents more than just its monetary value. It’s a symbolic rejection of Gage’s money and everything it represents. By giving it to David, she’s demonstrating that she doesn’t need or want Gage’s wealth. She’s offering him her trust and her future, untainted by the indecent proposal. It is a powerful symbol of her choice.
Is the ending of the book Indecent Proposal the same as the movie?
No, the book and movie have significant differences in the plot and resolution. In the book, the couple does not reconcile. The ending is far more ambiguous and deals with the long-term psychological effects of the experience on their relationship. The movie offers a more optimistic, Hollywood-style ending.
Did Diana ever truly love John Gage?
The film suggests Diana was flattered by Gage’s attention and the lifestyle he offered, but it never portrays her as genuinely in love with him. She was drawn to his power and wealth, perhaps as an escape from her financial struggles, but her heart remained with David. The film emphasizes the crucial difference between physical attraction and enduring love.
How does David react when Diana first approaches him in Las Vegas?
Initially, David is reserved and guarded. He’s hurt by the past and unsure if he can trust Diana again. He tests her by asking the pivotal question about repeating the proposal. His hesitation reflects the deep emotional scars left by their experience.
What is the significance of the craps table scene?
The craps table is a significant location. It symbolizes risk, chance, and the unpredictable nature of life. Diana’s winning streak can be interpreted as a metaphor for her taking control of her own destiny and reclaiming her power after a year of feeling lost and vulnerable.
Did Robert Redford (John Gage) ever comment on the movie’s ending?
Robert Redford, who played John Gage, has spoken about the film’s exploration of materialism and moral boundaries. He saw Gage as a catalyst for exploring the fragility of relationships and the potential impact of money on human values. He acknowledged the ending’s optimistic tone but emphasized the film’s underlying message about the importance of trust and commitment.
What themes does the movie Indecent Proposal explore?
Indecent Proposal explores several key themes, including the power of money, the nature of love and trust, the impact of social class, and the commodification of relationships. It raises questions about the limits of morality and the ethical dilemmas individuals face when confronted with extraordinary circumstances.
How did audiences react to the movie’s ending?
Audience reactions to the ending were mixed. Some found it satisfying and romantic, believing it reinforced the idea that true love can conquer all. Others felt it was unrealistic and simplistic, failing to adequately address the complex psychological damage caused by the indecent proposal. Critics, in particular, were often skeptical of the neatly resolved ending.
Was a sequel to Indecent Proposal ever considered?
Despite the movie’s box office success, a direct sequel was never seriously pursued. The premise of the film is inherently singular, and it would be difficult to create a compelling narrative that builds upon the original story without feeling repetitive or contrived.
What is the lasting impact of Indecent Proposal?
Despite the mixed critical reception, Indecent Proposal remains a culturally significant film. It sparked widespread debate about the ethics of transactional relationships and the value of love versus money. The film’s provocative premise continues to resonate with audiences, prompting discussions about the moral complexities of modern society. It solidified a fascinating snapshot of the 90’s and the allure and danger of unimaginable wealth.