No, you absolutely do not need to film Gateron Milky Yellow switches. While films can potentially improve the sound and wobble characteristics, they are not a mandatory component for enjoying these popular linear switches. Their inherent smoothness and relatively tight tolerances often make films an optional, rather than essential, modification.
The Rise of Switch Filming: A Keyboard Enthusiast’s Quest for Perfection
The mechanical keyboard community is constantly evolving, driven by a relentless pursuit of the perfect typing experience. This quest has led to the emergence of countless modifications, from lubing and spring swapping to the more specialized technique of switch filming. But what exactly is switch filming, and why has it become so prevalent?
What Are Switch Films and How Do They Work?
Switch films are thin sheets of plastic, typically made from polycarbonate or HTV, that are inserted between the top and bottom housings of a mechanical keyboard switch. Their primary purpose is to reduce housing wobble, the slight movement between these two parts. This wobble can manifest as a rattling or inconsistent sound, particularly with switches that have looser tolerances. By filling the gaps, switch films create a tighter, more secure fit, resulting in a cleaner, more refined sound signature and a potentially smoother keypress feel.
Why the Debate Around Gateron Milky Yellows?
Gateron Milky Yellow switches are renowned for their affordability, smoothness, and overall value. They are often recommended as excellent entry-level linear switches. One of their defining characteristics is that they are manufactured with relatively tighter tolerances compared to some other switches, which naturally minimizes housing wobble. This inherent design often raises the question: are switch films really necessary for these already smooth and stable switches? The answer, as we’ll explore further, is nuanced and depends heavily on individual preferences and expectations.
Examining the Potential Benefits of Filming Gateron Milky Yellows
While not a necessity, adding films to Gateron Milky Yellows can offer some benefits, albeit often subtle:
Improved Sound Profile
Even with their already relatively stable housings, switch films can further refine the sound of Gateron Milky Yellows. By minimizing even the slightest housing movement, films can contribute to a deeper, more solid, and less rattly sound signature. This improvement is particularly noticeable in higher-pitched keyboards or those with sensitive microphones that pick up subtle imperfections. The degree of sonic improvement will depend on the specific batch of switches and the quality of the films used.
Reduced Wobble (Sometimes)
As mentioned, Gateron Milky Yellows generally have acceptable wobble. However, manufacturing tolerances can vary, and some switches might exhibit slightly more movement than others. In these cases, films can effectively reduce wobble, leading to a more stable and consistent typing experience. This is especially noticeable on larger keycaps, which tend to amplify any existing wobble. It is important to note, however, that some users report little to no noticeable difference in wobble after filming.
Enhanced Consistency
By ensuring a tighter fit between the switch housings, films can contribute to a more consistent feel across the entire keyboard. This can be particularly beneficial for typists who prioritize uniformity and precision. However, the difference in consistency will likely be subtle for most users.
The Counterarguments: Why Filming Might Not Be Necessary
Despite the potential benefits, there are several reasons why filming Gateron Milky Yellows might not be worth the effort for some users:
Diminishing Returns
The most significant counterargument is the principle of diminishing returns. Gateron Milky Yellows are already relatively stable and smooth. Adding films provides a smaller improvement compared to the impact of filming switches with significantly looser housings. The effort and cost involved in filming may not justify the subtle improvements for many users.
Potential for Complications
While switch films are generally easy to install, there is always a small risk of damaging the switch during the process. Improper installation can even increase wobble if the film is not properly seated. Additionally, some films can be too thick, making the switch difficult to close or altering the keypress feel negatively.
Cost and Time Investment
Switch films can add to the overall cost of a keyboard build, especially for larger keyboards. Moreover, the process of installing films can be time-consuming, particularly for those new to keyboard modifications.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 12 frequently asked questions about filming Gateron Milky Yellow switches:
1. What type of switch films are best for Gateron Milky Yellows?
Generally, thinner films made from polycarbonate (PC) or HTV are recommended. These materials offer a good balance of flexibility and durability and are less likely to interfere with the switch’s operation. Popular brands include Deskeys Films and TX Films. Experimentation is key to finding what you prefer.
2. Will filming make my Gateron Milky Yellows sound “thoccier”?
Potentially, yes. By reducing housing wobble and creating a tighter fit, films can contribute to a deeper and more resonant sound signature, often described as “thoccier.” However, the overall sound also depends on other factors like the keycaps, case material, and plate material.
3. Can filming negatively affect the feel of my switches?
Yes, it’s possible. Overly thick films can compress the switch housings and alter the keypress feel, making it feel stiffer or less smooth. Choosing the right thickness of film is crucial.
4. How do I install switch films correctly?
Carefully open the switch using a switch opener. Place the film on the bottom housing, ensuring it’s properly seated around the switch stem. Then, carefully reassemble the switch.
5. Do I need to lube my switches before filming?
Lubing and filming are separate processes. While both can improve the sound and feel of your switches, they address different aspects. You can lube before or after filming, but lubing before is generally recommended to avoid having to reopen the filmed switch if you decide to lube later.
6. Are there any alternatives to switch films?
Yes, some users use small pieces of electrical tape or other thin materials to achieve a similar effect. However, switch films are generally considered a more reliable and consistent solution.
7. Where can I buy switch films?
Switch films are widely available from online retailers specializing in mechanical keyboard components. Popular stores include NovelKeys, KBDfans, and CannonKeys.
8. How do I know if my switches need filming?
Listen closely to your switches while typing. If you hear a noticeable rattling or inconsistent sound, or if you feel excessive wobble, filming might be beneficial. However, the best way to determine if filming is right for you is to experiment and compare the sound and feel of filmed and unfilmed switches.
9. Can filming damage my switches?
If done incorrectly, yes. Using excessive force when opening or closing the switch, or using overly thick films, can potentially damage the switch housings or stem. Proceed with caution and watch tutorial videos before attempting to film your switches.
10. What’s the difference between different types of switch film materials?
Polycarbonate (PC) films are generally more rigid and offer better sound dampening. HTV (Heat Transfer Vinyl) films are more flexible and can conform better to the shape of the switch housings. The best material depends on your personal preference and the specific switches you’re using.
11. Is filming worth it for a beginner?
For a complete beginner, focusing on basic modifications like lubing is often recommended before tackling switch filming. Once you’re comfortable with lubing, you can experiment with filming to see if it provides a noticeable improvement for you.
12. Are there any tools I need besides switch films?
A switch opener is essential for safely opening your switches. Tweezers can be helpful for handling the small switch films. A comfortable workspace and good lighting are also recommended.
Conclusion: A Matter of Personal Preference
Ultimately, whether or not you should film your Gateron Milky Yellow switches is a matter of personal preference. If you are a perfectionist seeking to squeeze every last drop of performance and refinement from your switches, filming might be worth exploring. However, if you are happy with the stock performance of these already excellent switches, or if you are new to keyboard modifications, filming might not be necessary. Experimentation is key to discovering what works best for you and your keyboard. The inherent quality of Gateron Milky Yellows means you’ll likely have a good typing experience regardless!