The pivotal moment when Cat Grant learns Kara Danvers is Supergirl unfolds gradually, culminating in Season 2, Episode 22, “Nevertheless, She Persisted”. However, the build-up to this revelation spans several episodes, as Cat meticulously pieces together clues and observes Kara’s increasingly suspicious behavior.
The Slow Burn: Planting the Seeds of Suspicion
Cat Grant’s brilliance lies in her intuitive understanding of people. She possesses an uncanny ability to see beneath the surface, a trait that makes her an exceptional media mogul and a formidable adversary. Her suspicion about Kara’s dual identity isn’t a sudden epiphany, but rather a meticulously crafted deduction built upon a foundation of observations and logical reasoning.
From the moment Kara arrives at CatCo, Cat senses something special about her. She sees Kara’s unwavering optimism, her inherent goodness, and her unwavering dedication, all qualities reminiscent of Supergirl. Cat observes Kara’s frequent disappearances, her uncanny knowledge of Kryptonian culture, and her peculiar interactions with Supergirl, leading her to suspect a deeper connection.
Several key events fuel Cat’s suspicions:
- Kara’s constant proximity to Supergirl emergencies: Cat notices that Kara is often conveniently absent whenever Supergirl is needed.
- Kara’s encyclopedic knowledge of Krypton: Despite being raised on Earth, Kara possesses an unusual and detailed understanding of Kryptonian history, culture, and technology.
- Subtle visual cues: Cat, being a sharp observer, picks up on subtle similarities between Kara’s demeanor and Supergirl’s mannerisms.
- Kara’s relationship with James Olsen: Cat recognizes the significance of Kara’s close relationship with James Olsen, who is known to have connections to Supergirl.
Cat doesn’t immediately confront Kara. Instead, she subtly tests her, probing her with pointed questions and observing her reactions. This cat-and-mouse game adds a layer of intrigue and suspense to their relationship, as both women engage in a battle of wits.
The Confrontation: “Nevertheless, She Persisted”
In “Nevertheless, She Persisted,” the final pieces of the puzzle fall into place. After spending time observing Kara, she confronts her. The specific words and setting are crucial: Cat calls Kara into her office and asks her directly: “I know you’re Supergirl. Don’t insult my intelligence by denying it.” This directness is characteristic of Cat, and Kara, caught off guard, doesn’t even attempt to deny the claim.
Cat’s understanding isn’t born from seeing Kara in costume; it’s from seeing Kara, the essence of who she is, and recognizing that essence aligns with the superhero she admired. This is a testament to both Cat’s perceptiveness and the unwavering goodness that defines Kara. This scene marks a significant turning point in their relationship, solidifying their bond and establishing Cat as a confidante and mentor to Kara.
The Significance of the Revelation
Cat knowing Kara’s secret provides Kara with someone to talk to and confide in outside of the DEO. It reinforces the recurring theme that ordinary people can see and understand the heroic spirit, independent of superpowers. Furthermore, Cat’s acceptance allows Kara to be more open about her identity, even if only to a select few.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 12 frequently asked questions about Cat Grant’s discovery of Supergirl’s identity, offering further insights and clarifications:
H3: When did Cat start suspecting Kara was Supergirl?
Cat’s suspicions began early in Season 1. Even though there is no specific episode that marks the beginning of her suspicion, she notices Kara’s strange behavior from her first day at CatCo. Her years of experience dealing with people’s public images allows her to notice things that others dismiss.
H3: What clues led Cat to believe Kara was Supergirl?
Several clues contributed to Cat’s suspicion. These included Kara’s constant absence during Supergirl emergencies, her knowledge of Krypton, her relationship with James Olsen, and subtle visual cues. Cat combined all of these observations, creating a compelling case in her mind.
H3: Why didn’t Cat reveal Kara’s identity publicly?
Cat, despite being a media mogul driven by ratings, had a strong sense of ethics. She recognized the potential danger that would come to Kara and those around her if Supergirl’s identity were revealed to the world. Cat chose to protect Kara, demonstrating a genuine affection for her.
H3: How did Kara react when Cat confronted her?
Kara was initially shocked when Cat confronted her. However, realizing that Cat already knew the truth, she didn’t try to deny it. Instead, she acknowledged Cat’s intelligence and accepted her knowledge of her secret.
H3: Did Cat ever help Supergirl in her battles?
While Cat didn’t directly participate in physical battles, she provided invaluable emotional support and guidance to Kara. Her wisdom and insight often helped Kara navigate difficult situations and make crucial decisions. Cat’s role was one of counsel, not combat.
H3: Did Cat ever reveal Kara’s secret to anyone else?
Cat remained true to her word and never revealed Kara’s secret to anyone else. She understood the importance of protecting Kara’s identity and respected her trust.
H3: How did Cat’s knowledge of Kara’s identity change their relationship?
Cat’s knowledge of Kara’s identity deepened their relationship, transforming it from a professional one to a more personal and intimate bond. Cat became a confidante and mentor to Kara, offering advice and support as she balanced her responsibilities as Supergirl and a young woman.
H3: Was Cat’s suspicion of Supergirl unique? Did others suspect Kara?
While others occasionally suspected Kara was Supergirl, Cat was the only one who successfully pieced together all the clues and definitively confirmed her identity. Her exceptional intuition and observation skills set her apart.
H3: Did Cat’s departure from CatCo affect Kara’s Supergirl duties?
While Cat’s departure was a significant loss for Kara personally, it didn’t directly impact her Supergirl duties. Kara continued to operate with the support of the DEO and her friends, but she missed Cat’s guidance and wisdom.
H3: How does Cat’s revelation compare to other superhero secret identity reveals?
Cat’s discovery of Kara’s identity is unique because it’s driven by observation and intuition, rather than a dramatic reveal in a moment of crisis. It’s a testament to her intelligence and insight, making it a memorable and satisfying moment in the series.
H3: What other characters knew about Kara being Supergirl?
Besides Cat Grant, characters like Alex Danvers, J’onn J’onzz, Winn Schott, James Olsen, and Lena Luthor knew Kara’s secret. The circle of trust grew over time, with each character playing a crucial role in supporting Kara’s mission.
H3: Why is Cat Grant such a significant character in the Supergirl narrative?
Cat Grant is a significant character because she represents the potential for human understanding and acceptance. She sees the inherent goodness in Kara and supports her mission to protect the world. She serves as a mentor, a friend, and a voice of reason, providing Kara with the strength and guidance she needs to be Supergirl. Her presence elevates the narrative, adding depth and complexity to the story of Supergirl.