While the titles are strikingly similar, American Horror Story (AHS) and American Horror Stories (AHStories) are distinct entities within the horror anthology universe. AHS unfolds as season-long narratives, exploring a single, overarching terrifying theme, whereas AHStories delivers self-contained, episodic horror tales, often within the same twisted universe.
The Core Difference: Anthology Format
The most significant differentiating factor lies in their anthology structure. AHS operates on a seasonal anthology format. Each season presents a new, self-contained story with a different setting, characters, and overarching theme. These themes have ranged from haunted houses and asylums to cults and apocalypses. While actors often return in different roles across seasons, the storylines rarely directly connect beyond Easter eggs and thematic parallels.
AHStories, on the other hand, functions as an episodic anthology. Each episode (or sometimes pair of episodes) tells a completely separate, independent horror story. Though some episodes feature recurring characters and locations, often linking back to the main AHS universe, the vast majority are standalone tales designed to deliver concise jolts of horror in a single sitting. This format allows for a broader range of horror subgenres and experimentation within the AHS brand.
Deeper Dive: Production and Creative Team
While both shows are the brainchild of Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk, the demands of their respective formats influence production. AHS requires a more sustained narrative arc, necessitating detailed world-building and character development over multiple episodes. This results in a more focused and carefully crafted plot.
AHStories benefits from its episodic nature. It allows for greater flexibility in casting, writing, and directing. The production timeline is compressed, allowing for a faster turnover of episodes and the opportunity to showcase a wider array of talent. This difference in production contributes to the distinct feel of each show.
Audience Reception and Critical Acclaim
AHS garnered significant critical acclaim and a dedicated fan base for its bold storytelling, striking visuals, and stellar performances. Its impact on the horror genre is undeniable, revitalizing the anthology format on television. The longer season format allows for deeper character exploration and complex plot development, which has often been praised.
AHStories has had a more mixed reception. While the episodic format provides quick bursts of horror, some critics and viewers have found the individual stories to be less developed and impactful compared to the longer, more intricate narratives of AHS. However, the show’s willingness to experiment with different horror subgenres and its connection to the established AHS universe remains a draw for many viewers.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some common questions that arise when distinguishing between American Horror Story and American Horror Stories:
What makes American Horror Story so unique?
AHS distinguishes itself through its commitment to exploring complex and often taboo themes within the horror genre. Each season delves into societal anxieties, historical events, and psychological traumas, using horror as a lens to examine these issues. The consistent use of a core group of actors playing different roles each season also creates a unique sense of familiarity and connection for viewers.
Is it necessary to watch AHS seasons in order?
While not strictly necessary, watching AHS seasons in order enhances the viewing experience. While each season is a standalone story, there are often subtle references, connections, and recurring themes that will be more appreciated by those who have followed the series from the beginning. Some seasons also feature characters or events that are mentioned in later seasons.
Does American Horror Stories have any connection to the main AHS universe?
Yes, many episodes of AHStories are explicitly connected to the main AHS universe. They often feature locations, characters, and events that have been established in previous seasons of AHS. This provides fans with an opportunity to revisit familiar elements and explore them in new ways.
Are all the episodes of American Horror Stories standalone?
No, while most episodes are standalone, some episodes of AHStories are structured as two-part stories that continue across multiple episodes. Additionally, some episodes may introduce characters or storylines that are revisited in later episodes, blurring the line between standalone and interconnected narratives.
Which show is scarier, American Horror Story or American Horror Stories?
Scary is subjective, but generally, American Horror Story is considered more psychologically disturbing, due to the longer format allowing for deeper exploration of disturbing themes. American Horror Stories often relies more on shock value and jump scares. Ultimately, it depends on individual preferences.
Which show is better for newcomers to the AHS franchise?
American Horror Stories might be a better entry point for newcomers due to its self-contained episodic format. It allows viewers to sample different types of horror within the AHS universe without committing to a longer season-long arc. If they enjoy a particular episode or theme, they might be more inclined to explore the corresponding season of AHS.
Where can I watch American Horror Story and American Horror Stories?
Both shows are typically available on FX and Hulu. Depending on your region, they may also be available on other streaming platforms or through cable providers.
Are there any specific episodes of American Horror Stories that directly connect to AHS seasons?
Yes, some episodes of AHStories directly connect to AHS seasons. For instance, several episodes are set in or reference the Murder House (from AHS: Murder House), creating a direct link to the original season.
Will there be future seasons of American Horror Story and American Horror Stories?
As of the current date, both shows have been renewed for future seasons. Fans can expect more chilling tales from both the seasonal anthology format of AHS and the episodic format of AHStories.
How are the themes chosen for each season of American Horror Story?
Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk often draw inspiration from real-life events, historical figures, and societal anxieties when choosing the themes for each season of AHS. They aim to create stories that are both terrifying and relevant, reflecting the fears and concerns of the modern world.
Does the same cast appear in both American Horror Story and American Horror Stories?
Yes, many actors who have appeared in American Horror Story have also appeared in American Horror Stories. This includes fan favorites like Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, Lily Rabe, and Jessica Lange (although Lange has primarily appeared in AHS). The same actors often play different roles in each show, showcasing their versatility.
What is the overall impact of American Horror Story on the horror television landscape?
American Horror Story has had a profound impact on the horror television landscape. It revitalized the anthology format, demonstrated the viability of horror on premium cable, and paved the way for other successful horror series. The show’s bold storytelling, striking visuals, and talented cast have made it a cultural phenomenon and a major influence on the genre.