No, the 1979 film “The Amityville Horror,” while inspired by real events, did not use the actual house at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York for its primary filming location. Filmmakers opted for a different house to avoid the disruptions and potential issues associated with filming at the real location, choosing a similar-looking residence in Toms River, New Jersey.
The Search for Authenticity: Filming “The Amityville Horror”
The enduring appeal of “The Amityville Horror” stems from its alleged basis in a true story. Ronald DeFeo Jr.’s horrific murders of his family in 1974, followed by the Lutz family’s brief and terrifying residency in the same house, fueled a global fascination with the supernatural. However, the transition from page to screen involved compromises, especially regarding the filming location.
Why Not the Real House?
Several factors contributed to the decision to film elsewhere. The original Amityville house was, understandably, a sensitive location. The memories of the DeFeo murders were still raw, and filming a horror movie on the premises would have been disrespectful and potentially disruptive to the current occupants (who had purchased the house after the Lutz family moved out).
Furthermore, obtaining permits for extensive filming in a residential neighborhood can be challenging. A film crew brings equipment, noise, and increased traffic, all of which can disrupt the peace and quiet. The producers likely weighed these logistical hurdles against the desire for complete authenticity.
The House That Played the Part: Toms River, NJ
The house chosen in Toms River, New Jersey, shared several key visual similarities with the original Amityville home. Most notably, it featured the distinctive Dutch Colonial architectural style and the iconic quarter-moon windows that had become synonymous with the Amityville legend.
However, the filmmakers also made deliberate alterations to the Toms River house to further resemble the Amityville residence as it was portrayed in the book and perceived by the public. This involved adding or modifying features to enhance the film’s aesthetic and reinforce the sense of unease and foreboding.
Minimizing Disturbances at the Real Amityville Location
While the main filming did not occur at 112 Ocean Avenue, some exterior shots were captured there to provide establishing scenes and a sense of connection to the true story. These shots were carefully planned and executed to minimize any disruption to the residents and the surrounding community.
It’s important to note that the visual representation of the Amityville house in the film is a composite of the real house and the Toms River substitute, crafted to maximize cinematic impact.
Beyond the Film: The Amityville House in Reality
The real house at 112 Ocean Avenue has undergone several renovations and changes in ownership since the Lutz family moved out. It has been remodeled to alter its appearance and distance itself from the notorious past. The quarter-moon windows, for instance, were removed and replaced with standard rectangular windows.
The Ongoing Fascination
Despite these changes, the Amityville house continues to draw visitors and spark curiosity. Its association with the DeFeo murders and the Lutz family’s alleged paranormal experiences ensures its place in the annals of American true crime and paranormal lore.
The Enduring Legacy
The film “The Amityville Horror,” regardless of its factual accuracy, cemented the image of the Amityville house in popular culture. The house in Toms River, therefore, became forever linked to the Amityville legend, even though it was just a stand-in.
FAQs About the Amityville Horror House and Film
Here are some frequently asked questions surrounding the “Amityville Horror” and the use of the real house in the film:
1. What is the address of the real Amityville Horror house?
The real house is located at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York. It is a private residence and should not be disturbed.
2. Why did the Lutz family leave the Amityville house?
The Lutz family claimed to have experienced a series of terrifying paranormal events during their 28-day stay in the house, including moving objects, strange noises, and disturbing visions. Their experiences formed the basis of the book and subsequent films. It’s important to note that these claims are heavily debated and have been questioned by skeptics.
3. Has anyone else lived in the Amityville house since the Lutz family?
Yes, several families have lived in the house since the Lutz family. None of them have reported similar experiences to the extent described by the Lutzes.
4. Did the DeFeo family really die in the house?
Yes, Ronald DeFeo Jr. murdered his parents and four siblings in the house in 1974. He was convicted of the murders and sentenced to life in prison.
5. Were the quarter-moon windows on the real Amityville house?
Yes, the distinctive quarter-moon windows were a prominent feature of the real Amityville house at the time of the DeFeo murders and the Lutz family’s occupancy. However, they have since been removed.
6. What happened to the house used for filming in Toms River, NJ?
The house used for filming in Toms River, NJ, has also undergone renovations and changes in ownership. It still stands, but it has been altered to reduce its resemblance to the Amityville house.
7. Are there any tours of the Amityville house?
No, there are no official tours of the Amityville house. It is a private residence, and trespassing is illegal.
8. What is the controversy surrounding “The Amityville Horror” story?
The primary controversy revolves around the veracity of the Lutz family’s claims. Skeptics argue that their story was fabricated or exaggerated for financial gain, while proponents maintain that their experiences were genuine. The truth likely lies somewhere in between.
9. How accurate is the film “The Amityville Horror” to the actual events?
The film takes significant liberties with the story. While it’s based on the Lutz family’s account, it embellishes and dramatizes events for entertainment purposes. It should be viewed as a work of fiction inspired by real events, rather than a factual representation.
10. Were any other locations used in the filming of “The Amityville Horror”?
Yes, in addition to the Toms River house and some exterior shots of the real Amityville house, other locations in New Jersey and New York were used for interior scenes and supporting shots.
11. Does the current owner of 112 Ocean Avenue believe in the haunting?
It’s difficult to know definitively what the current owner believes. Due to the constant attention and notoriety surrounding the house, owners often maintain a private stance on the alleged hauntings. Publicly expressing beliefs either way can fuel further unwanted attention.
12. Where can I find more information about the Amityville Horror case and the house?
Numerous books, documentaries, and online resources explore the Amityville Horror case. However, it’s important to approach these sources with a critical eye and consider the various perspectives and biases involved. Search reputable sources for historical records, court documents, and interviews with those involved to form your own informed opinion. Pay close attention to sources that differentiate between verified facts and anecdotal claims.