In the classic “The Engagement, Part 2” episode of Seinfeld, Jerry’s cryptic statement about a certain “he” generates significant fan speculation. Jerry is most likely referring to NBC executive Rick Corcoran, who, according to writer Peter Mehlman, vehemently disliked the show and actively tried to cancel it.
The Context: A Complicated Relationship
The episode, a culmination of George’s impulsive engagement and the general unraveling of the core four, finds Jerry in a particularly agitated state. He’s struggling with Elaine’s negativity, George’s farcical wedding plans, and Kramer’s increasingly bizarre schemes. Amidst this chaos, Jerry makes a passing comment about someone actively working against him. This seemingly innocuous remark has fueled endless debates within the Seinfeld fandom.
The Key Line
The pivotal line occurs when Jerry laments his situation to Elaine and George: “He’s out there, and he’s gonna get me.” This statement is not explored further in the episode, leaving viewers to speculate about the identity of the antagonistic “he.”
The Leading Theory: Rick Corcoran
While several possibilities have been suggested, the most credible and widely accepted theory points to Rick Corcoran, a programming executive at NBC during Seinfeld‘s early years. Writer Peter Mehlman revealed in interviews that Corcoran was not a fan of the show and actively tried to see it canceled.
Evidence Supporting the Corcoran Theory
- Insider Knowledge: Mehlman’s direct connection to the show and his inside knowledge lend significant weight to his claim. He was in a position to know about the internal power struggles and the executive opposition to Seinfeld.
- Early Season Struggles: Seinfeld faced cancellation several times during its first few seasons due to low ratings and network skepticism. Corcoran’s alleged dislike would have exacerbated these challenges.
- Timing of the Episode: “The Engagement, Part 2” aired during a period when Seinfeld, despite gaining popularity, was still fighting for its place on NBC’s schedule. The creative team may have been feeling the pressure from executives like Corcoran.
Other Possible Candidates
Although Corcoran is the most plausible answer, other theories have circulated over the years. Let’s examine some alternative possibilities:
Larry David
Some speculate that Jerry might be referring to Larry David, the co-creator and head writer of Seinfeld. This theory suggests that the line is a meta-commentary on the creative tensions between Jerry Seinfeld and Larry David. However, this is less likely, as their partnership, while undoubtedly intense, was largely collaborative, not antagonistic.
A Generic Network Executive
Another possibility is that the “he” is a generic representation of the network executives who frequently interfered with the show’s creative process. This is a more general interpretation and lacks the specific animosity implied in Jerry’s statement.
A Fictional Character
Some fans humorously suggest that the “he” could be a fictional character from Jerry’s stand-up routines or a future episode. While this is unlikely, it highlights the ambiguity of the line and the endless possibilities for interpretation.
Final Verdict: Corcoran Remains the Strongest Contender
While absolute certainty is impossible, the evidence overwhelmingly supports the Rick Corcoran theory. Mehlman’s account, coupled with the context of Seinfeld‘s early struggles with NBC, makes Corcoran the most likely candidate for the mysterious “he” that Jerry fears in “The Engagement, Part 2.”
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
FAQ 1: Who is Rick Corcoran?
Rick Corcoran was an NBC executive during the early years of Seinfeld. He held a programming position that allowed him influence over which shows were renewed and canceled.
FAQ 2: Why did Rick Corcoran dislike Seinfeld?
The specific reasons for Corcoran’s dislike are not publicly known. However, it is speculated that he found the show’s “show about nothing” concept unconventional and unappealing. He may have also questioned its commercial viability.
FAQ 3: Did Corcoran actively try to cancel Seinfeld?
According to writer Peter Mehlman, yes, Corcoran actively tried to cancel Seinfeld. He allegedly voiced his disapproval within NBC and may have attempted to sabotage the show’s success.
FAQ 4: Is there any direct confirmation from Jerry Seinfeld or Larry David?
No, neither Jerry Seinfeld nor Larry David has publicly confirmed or denied the Corcoran theory. They have remained tight-lipped about the specific identity of the “he.”
FAQ 5: How reliable is Peter Mehlman’s account?
Peter Mehlman was a key writer on Seinfeld, contributing to many of the show’s most memorable episodes. His inside knowledge and direct connection to the show make his account highly reliable.
FAQ 6: Are there any other episodes that allude to network interference?
While no other episode explicitly names a specific executive, several episodes satirize the meddling of network executives in the creative process. This suggests that the Seinfeld team was frequently frustrated by network demands.
FAQ 7: What impact did Corcoran’s alleged dislike have on Seinfeld?
Corcoran’s opposition likely made it more difficult for Seinfeld to secure renewals and gain a stable foothold on NBC’s schedule. The show faced cancellation several times during its early seasons.
FAQ 8: How did Seinfeld ultimately overcome the network’s skepticism?
Seinfeld ultimately succeeded due to its unique comedic style, strong writing, and growing fanbase. As ratings improved, NBC became more willing to invest in the show.
FAQ 9: Is it common for network executives to dislike successful shows?
It’s not uncommon for network executives to have differing opinions about what constitutes a successful show. Creative disagreements and differing visions are a natural part of the television industry.
FAQ 10: What does this incident reveal about the power dynamics in television?
The Corcoran situation highlights the significant power that network executives wield over television shows. Their decisions can determine the fate of a program, regardless of its creative merit or audience appeal.
FAQ 11: Why has the “he” mystery remained so popular among Seinfeld fans?
The mystery surrounding Jerry’s “he” resonates with fans because it’s an intriguing behind-the-scenes glimpse into the inner workings of a beloved television show. The ambiguity of the line also allows for endless speculation and debate.
FAQ 12: Is it possible we’ll ever know for sure who Jerry was talking about?
While it’s possible, but unlikely, that Jerry Seinfeld or Larry David will definitively reveal the identity of the “he,” the Rick Corcoran theory remains the most compelling and well-supported explanation. The mystery, however, is part of what makes this Seinfeld moment so enduring.