Toby Flenderson, Dunder Mifflin Scranton’s long-suffering Human Resources representative, temporarily abandons his post for Costa Rica. He eventually returns, much to Michael Scott’s dismay, in Season 7, Episode 1, “Nepotism”.
The Unwanted Homecoming: Toby’s Return Detailed
Toby’s absence in Season 6 was a fleeting moment of joy for Michael, but alas, it couldn’t last. In the season premiere of Season 7, “Nepotism,” Toby unexpectedly reappears, tanned and slightly more relaxed (although still incredibly awkward). He explains that he had a terrible experience in Costa Rica, contracting a debilitating illness that forced him to return to Scranton.
The episode hilariously captures Michael’s utter despair at Toby’s return. His exaggerated reactions and attempts to sabotage Toby’s re-integration into the office provide the episode with its comedic core. The tension between the two is palpable and sets the stage for the remaining episodes of Season 7, marked by Michael’s escalating antagonism towards Toby. While the rest of the office largely ignores (or pities) Toby, Michael’s vitriol remains a constant, often disrupting the flow of the workday and creating uncomfortable situations.
The Impact of Toby’s Return
Toby’s return to the office significantly impacts the dynamics within Dunder Mifflin Scranton. It reinforces Michael’s character as someone unable to control his emotions and often acting inappropriately. It also perpetuates Toby’s image as the downtrodden and perpetually unfortunate HR representative, a role he seems destined to fulfill despite his attempts to break free. The renewed Michael-Toby conflict becomes a recurring comedic device throughout the remainder of Michael’s tenure at Dunder Mifflin.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Toby Flenderson’s Return
Here are some common questions surrounding Toby’s departure and return to The Office:
1. Why Did Toby Leave for Costa Rica in the First Place?
Toby announces his decision to leave for Costa Rica at the end of Season 6, specifically in the episode “Whistleblower”. He hopes to start a new life and potentially become a writer. He envisions a simpler, more fulfilling existence away from Scranton and, more importantly, away from Michael Scott.
2. What Episode Does Toby Leave in?
Toby officially departs for Costa Rica in the Season 6 finale, “Whistleblower”. This episode features various storylines, including the company-wide crisis, but Toby’s farewell is a key part of the ending.
3. How Long Was Toby Gone From The Office?
Toby is absent for the entirety of Season 6, Part 2, and then returns at the start of Season 7. So his absence spans approximately half a season.
4. What Made Toby Come Back From Costa Rica So Quickly?
Toby’s plan to live a carefree life in Costa Rica backfires dramatically. He contracts a mysterious illness, potentially malaria, and finds the experience far from idyllic. The specific nature of his illness is never fully explained, adding to the comedic absurdity. His doctor advises him to return to the United States for proper medical care.
5. How Does Michael React to Toby’s Return?
Michael’s reaction is, predictably, one of extreme dismay and anger. He is visibly distraught and vocal about his displeasure. He sees Toby as a constant source of annoyance and actively tries to make his life miserable, employing various childish pranks and insults. Michael’s hatred for Toby is a recurring theme in the series.
6. What Does Toby Say Happened to Him in Costa Rica?
Toby vaguely describes his experience as terrible and unhealthy, mentioning his illness and the difficulties he faced adjusting to a new culture. He’s hesitant to provide specific details, hinting that the experience was quite traumatic.
7. Does Anyone Else at Dunder Mifflin Care About Toby’s Return?
While the rest of the office doesn’t share Michael’s level of animosity towards Toby, they also don’t express overwhelming enthusiasm about his return. Most colleagues display a sense of mild pity or indifference towards him.
8. Does Toby Ever Successfully Leave Dunder Mifflin For Good?
Eventually, yes! Toby leaves Dunder Mifflin permanently in Season 9, Episode 25, “Finale.” He attends Pam and Jim’s Q&A panel and announces that he’s moving to New York City to be closer to his daughter Sasha and attempt to write his Chad Flenderson novels.
9. What is Toby’s Job Title and Responsibilities at Dunder Mifflin?
Toby is the Human Resources representative for the Scranton branch of Dunder Mifflin. His responsibilities include enforcing company policies, handling employee complaints, and managing benefits. However, he often struggles to assert his authority, especially when dealing with Michael Scott’s inappropriate behavior.
10. Does Toby Ever Stand Up For Himself Against Michael?
Rarely. Toby is generally passive and avoids confrontation. However, there are occasional moments where he attempts to assert himself, usually with little success. These instances often serve to highlight his helplessness and Michael’s dominance.
11. How Does Toby’s Return Affect His Relationship With Pam?
Toby harbors a secret, unrequited crush on Pam Beesly throughout the series. His return doesn’t drastically alter their relationship. He continues to admire her from afar, although his interactions with her remain awkward and mostly one-sided. His infatuation with Pam is a source of humor, but also a reflection of his loneliness.
12. Is There a Real-World Reason Why Toby Left Temporarily?
Yes, there is. Paul Lieberstein, the actor who plays Toby, took a temporary leave from acting to serve as showrunner for The Office during Seasons 5-8. The storyline about Toby’s trip to Costa Rica was created to accommodate his absence from the screen while he was still heavily involved behind the scenes.