Detective Bobby Simone, portrayed by the acclaimed Jimmy Smits, was a cornerstone of NYPD Blue for six seasons. His complex character, moral compass, and evolving relationship with Detective Andy Sipowicz captivated audiences. But his departure was sudden and tragic. Detective Bobby Simone dies in “Big Bang Theory” (Season 6, Episode 13). His death, due to complications from a heart condition, marked a pivotal moment in the series, profoundly impacting Sipowicz and the entire 15th Precinct.
The Death of Simone: A Detailed Look
The episode, “Big Bang Theory,” chronicles Simone’s valiant battle with his heart condition. Initially diagnosed earlier in the series, his condition worsens significantly in this episode. While the detective is determined to continue working and making a difference, his deteriorating health becomes undeniable. The narrative emphasizes the emotional toll on both Simone and those around him, particularly Andy Sipowicz.
The heart transplant offers a glimmer of hope, but ultimately proves unsuccessful. Simone’s death is handled with sensitivity and realism, avoiding sensationalism and focusing instead on the raw grief experienced by his colleagues and loved ones. It’s a testament to the show’s commitment to depicting the human side of law enforcement. His passing leaves a void that is felt throughout the remaining seasons of the show.
The Aftermath and Impact
Simone’s death served as a significant turning point for Sipowicz. The loss of his closest friend and partner forced Sipowicz to confront his own mortality and re-evaluate his life. He became more reflective, more vulnerable, and arguably, more compassionate. The event also impacted the dynamics within the 15th Precinct, as the detectives grappled with the loss of a respected and admired colleague.
The ripple effects of Simone’s death extended beyond the characters. It resonated with viewers, who had grown attached to the nuanced portrayal of Simone and his relationship with Sipowicz. The episode became a benchmark for its emotional depth and realistic portrayal of grief, solidifying NYPD Blue’s reputation as a groundbreaking and impactful police procedural.
Frequently Asked Questions About Simone’s Death in NYPD Blue
Here are some frequently asked questions regarding the circumstances surrounding Detective Simone’s death in NYPD Blue:
Why Did Jimmy Smits Leave NYPD Blue?
Jimmy Smits decided to leave NYPD Blue after his six-year contract expired. He reportedly wanted to pursue other acting opportunities and felt that Simone’s storyline had run its course. Smits has stated in interviews that he wanted to avoid the character becoming stale and preferred to exit while the character was still strong and respected.
What Specific Heart Condition Did Simone Have?
While the specific type of heart condition wasn’t explicitly named in the series, it was portrayed as a severe and progressive ailment requiring a heart transplant. The writers focused on the symptoms and the impact on Simone’s health and ability to perform his duties as a detective rather than delving into technical medical details.
How Did Simone’s Death Affect Andy Sipowicz?
Simone’s death profoundly affected Andy Sipowicz. It forced him to confront his own mortality and reconsider his life choices. He became more reflective, and his relationship with his son, Theo, deepened. It also led to significant character development, making him a more compassionate and empathetic individual. Many argue this was a crucial point in transforming Sipowicz from a problematic character into a more sympathetic one.
Did Simone’s Death Cause a Ratings Drop for NYPD Blue?
While ratings initially dipped slightly after Simone’s death, NYPD Blue remained a popular show for several more seasons. The show’s strong writing, compelling characters, and realistic storylines helped it maintain a loyal audience. The writers introduced new characters and storylines to fill the void left by Simone’s departure.
What Was the Critical Reception of “Big Bang Theory,” the Episode Where Simone Dies?
“Big Bang Theory” received overwhelmingly positive reviews from critics. Many praised the episode’s emotional depth, realistic portrayal of grief, and Jimmy Smits’ performance. It is often cited as one of the most memorable and impactful episodes in NYPD Blue’s history.
Was Simone’s Death Considered Controversial?
Some viewers found Simone’s death to be a sad and unnecessary plot development. However, most critics and fans acknowledged that it served a crucial purpose in advancing the storyline and developing Sipowicz’s character. While sad, many felt it elevated the show’s overall quality.
What Happened to Simone’s Wife, Diane Russell, After His Death?
Detective Diane Russell, portrayed by Kim Delaney, grieves Simone’s death deeply. She continues to work at the 15th Precinct and eventually enters into a relationship with Detective Baldwin Jones. The series explores her struggles with grief and her attempts to move forward with her life.
Did the Show Ever Explore Simone’s Background Before He Met Sipowicz?
The series occasionally hinted at Simone’s past, including his experiences as a marine and his previous relationships. However, the show primarily focused on his present life and his partnership with Sipowicz. Detailed exploration of his pre-NYPD Blue life remained relatively limited.
How Did Simone’s Death Compare to Other Major Character Deaths in TV History?
Simone’s death is often compared to other iconic television deaths, such as those of Henry Blake on MAS*H or George O’Malley on Grey’s Anatomy. All these deaths served to shock audiences and force the remaining characters to confront their own vulnerabilities. Simone’s death was particularly impactful because of the close bond he shared with Sipowicz.
What Was Jimmy Smits’ Reaction to the Way Simone’s Character Was Written Out of the Show?
Jimmy Smits has expressed satisfaction with the way Simone’s character was written out of NYPD Blue. He felt that the storyline was handled with sensitivity and respect, and he appreciated the opportunity to portray such a complex and nuanced character.
Did Dennis Franz (Sipowicz) Influence the Decision to Kill Off Simone?
Dennis Franz, who played Andy Sipowicz, reportedly did not influence the decision to kill off Simone. The writers and producers made the decision based on what they believed was best for the storyline and character development. Franz, however, embraced the opportunity to explore Sipowicz’s grief and transformation.
Where Can I Watch “Big Bang Theory” (Season 6, Episode 13) and Other Episodes of NYPD Blue?
NYPD Blue, including “Big Bang Theory,” is available for streaming on various platforms, depending on your region and subscription services. Some of the common platforms include Hulu, Amazon Prime Video (with add-ons), and through purchase options on platforms like iTunes or Google Play. Check your local listings and streaming services for availability.