Emily Dickinson (portrayed by Hailee Steinfeld) and Susan Huntington Gilbert (Ella Hunt)’s complex relationship is a cornerstone of the Apple TV+ series “Dickinson,” and their intimate moments are carefully depicted. While a literal “sleeping together” scene isn’t explicitly shown, the implication of their physical intimacy is strongly suggested in Season 1, Episode 8, titled “Wild Nights.” This episode serves as a pivotal moment in their evolving connection.
Decoding the “Wild Nights” Episode: More Than Just Subtext
The connection between Emily and Sue is never presented as a simple, straightforward romantic relationship. It’s steeped in intellectual companionship, artistic inspiration, deep-seated longing, and societal constraints. To pinpoint a singular “sleeping together” scene diminishes the nuances and layered symbolism woven throughout their narrative. Instead, we need to examine the build-up to “Wild Nights” and its aftermath to fully understand the episode’s significance.
Contextualizing the Relationship Before Episode 8
Prior to “Wild Nights,” the series meticulously establishes the deep bond between Emily and Sue. Sue, often presented as the more worldly and ambitious of the two, provides Emily with intellectual stimulation and a much-needed connection to the outside world. Emily, in turn, offers Sue a sanctuary of authenticity and unwavering adoration. Their interactions are filled with longing glances, whispered confessions, and shared dreams, all underscored by the repressive societal norms of the 19th century.
Analyzing the Impact of “Wild Nights”
The episode itself is fraught with emotional tension. Emily wrestles with her growing feelings for Sue, compounded by Sue’s impending marriage to Emily’s brother, Austin. The episode culminates in a scene where the two women are alone in Emily’s bedroom, sharing a deeply intimate moment. While a literal depiction of sexual activity isn’t shown, the emotional intimacy is undeniable, and the scene strongly implies a physical culmination of their feelings. The framing, the performances, and the overall tone of the episode all contribute to this interpretation. The unspoken words and lingering looks speak volumes.
The Significance of Implied Intimacy
“Dickinson” often uses metaphor and symbolism to portray Emily’s inner life. Rather than explicitly showing every intimate moment, the series often chooses to suggest them, leaving room for interpretation and focusing on the emotional and intellectual aspects of the relationship. This approach is arguably more powerful, reflecting the constrained social environment in which Emily and Sue lived and highlighting the courage and defiance inherent in their love. The ambiguity also invites the audience to actively participate in interpreting their connection, making it a richer and more rewarding experience.
Navigating the Complexities: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
To further clarify the intricacies of Emily and Sue’s relationship in “Dickinson,” consider these FAQs:
FAQ 1: Did Emily Dickinson, the real person, have a relationship with Susan Huntington Gilbert?
Historical evidence suggests a deep and significant relationship between Emily Dickinson and Susan Huntington Gilbert, who later married Emily’s brother, Austin. While the exact nature of their relationship is debated by scholars, their voluminous correspondence reveals a profound intellectual and emotional bond. Many believe their letters hint at a romantic and possibly physical relationship.
FAQ 2: What makes “Dickinson’s” portrayal of their relationship unique?
“Dickinson” modernizes the narrative by openly exploring the potential for a queer relationship between Emily and Sue. It uses contemporary language and music to bridge the gap between the 19th century and the present, making their struggles and desires relatable to a modern audience.
FAQ 3: How does the show portray the societal pressures on Emily and Sue?
The show vividly depicts the societal constraints placed upon women in the 19th century. Emily and Sue are both limited by their gender roles and the expectations of marriage and domesticity. Their relationship is further complicated by Sue’s marriage to Austin, creating a love triangle fraught with jealousy and conflict.
FAQ 4: Does Sue ever reciprocate Emily’s feelings openly?
Sue’s feelings for Emily are complex and often contradictory. She clearly cares deeply for Emily, but she also desires social acceptance and financial security, which she believes marriage to Austin will provide. She often struggles to reconcile her desires for Emily with the limitations of her circumstances. Her actions are often interpreted as both a reciprocation and rejection of Emily’s love.
FAQ 5: How does Austin’s presence affect Emily and Sue’s relationship?
Austin’s marriage to Sue creates a significant barrier in Emily and Sue’s relationship. It forces them to navigate their feelings for each other within the confines of societal expectations and familial obligations. Austin is often portrayed as oblivious to the true depth of the connection between his wife and his sister.
FAQ 6: Are there other hints of intimacy between Emily and Sue in other episodes?
Yes, throughout the series, there are numerous scenes that suggest intimacy between Emily and Sue. These include shared glances, whispered conversations, longing touches, and symbolic imagery that hints at their emotional and possibly physical connection. The show consistently uses subtext and implication to convey the depth of their relationship.
FAQ 7: What are some examples of symbolic imagery used to represent their relationship?
Recurring motifs such as flowers, particularly the violet (often associated with lesbian relationships), and shared poems with romantic undertones often symbolize their connection. Dreams and fantasies also provide a glimpse into Emily’s innermost desires and her feelings for Sue.
FAQ 8: How does the show use music to enhance their relationship’s portrayal?
The soundtrack frequently features modern pop music with lyrics that reflect the emotional turmoil and longing experienced by Emily and Sue. This juxtaposition of contemporary music with the 19th-century setting creates a powerful emotional resonance and highlights the timeless nature of their love.
FAQ 9: Is the show historically accurate in its depiction of Emily and Sue’s relationship?
While “Dickinson” takes creative liberties with historical facts, it is grounded in the documented correspondence between Emily Dickinson and Susan Huntington Gilbert. The show explores the potential for a romantic relationship based on this evidence, but it is important to remember that it is a fictionalized interpretation.
FAQ 10: How does the show address the homophobia of the time period?
The show directly confronts the homophobia and societal stigma surrounding same-sex relationships in the 19th century. Emily and Sue are forced to conceal their feelings and navigate their relationship in secret, fearing social ostracism and the potential consequences of being discovered.
FAQ 11: What impact does Sue’s eventual motherhood have on her relationship with Emily?
Sue’s roles as wife and mother further complicate her relationship with Emily. It introduces new responsibilities and expectations that pull her further away from Emily, forcing them to confront the limitations of their connection within the confines of her domestic life.
FAQ 12: Does the series ever definitively label Emily and Sue’s relationship?
The series deliberately avoids definitively labeling their relationship. It focuses on the complexity of their emotions, the challenges they face, and the enduring bond they share. This ambiguity allows viewers to interpret their relationship in their own way, fostering a deeper connection to the characters and their story.